Skip to content

Conversation

@paridhimalviya
Copy link

Exercise_1 : Implement Stack using Array.

Exercise_2 : Implement Stack using Linked List.

Exercise_3 : Implement Singly Linked List.

@super30admin
Copy link
Owner

The student's solution demonstrates a good understanding of linked lists and stacks, with implementations in Swift. Here's a detailed evaluation:

  1. Correctness:
  • The LinkedList implementation correctly handles append and prepend operations.
  • The Stack implementation using an array is correct and follows standard practices.
  • The LinkedListToStackAdapter correctly implements stack operations using a linked list.
  • The SinglyLinkedList implementation correctly handles push and append operations.
  1. Time Complexity:
  • LinkedList operations (append/prepend): O(1)
  • Stack operations (push/pop/peek): O(1)
  • LinkedListToStackAdapter operations: O(1) for all operations
  • SinglyLinkedList operations: O(1) for push/append
  1. Space Complexity:
  • All implementations use O(n) space where n is the number of elements.
  1. Code Quality:
  • Good use of Swift features like generics, extensions, and protocols.
  • Clear separation of concerns between different data structures.
  • Good documentation and comments explaining the code.
  • Some minor issues:
    • In LinkedListToStackAdapter, the description property could be simplified by using the existing LLLinkedList's description.
    • Some redundant code between different linked list implementations (Node classes could potentially be shared).
    • The date in the file headers is incorrect (12/16/25 and 12/17/25).
  1. Efficiency:
  • The implementations are generally efficient.
  • One potential optimization would be to share the Node class between different linked list implementations to reduce code duplication.
  • The Stack implementation could benefit from making storage private to enforce encapsulation.

Overall, the solution is well-structured and demonstrates a good understanding of the concepts. The main areas for improvement are reducing code duplication and improving encapsulation.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

2 participants