sandbox-permissions: Add docs for conditional permissions

docs/sandbox-permissions.rst

@@ -335,7 +335,7 @@
 The rule ``all`` enumerates every USB device. There is no further rule
 allowed in the query.
 
 The ``vnd`` and ``dev`` rules specify a USB vendor and a USB device ID
 respectively. A vendor can be specified alone, but a device rule
 always comes with a vendor rule as a device ID is only unique within a
 vendor. Vendor and device ID are specified with 4 digit hex
@@ -472,6 +472,104 @@
 of the subpath can be consistently pre-determined. Block device naming
 depends on the kernel/fstab configuration and cannot be pre-determined.
 
+Conditional permissions
+-----------------------
+
+Since 1.17.0, Flatpak supports conditional permissions which allows
+them to be granted only when certain runtime conditions are satisfied
+and fallback otherwise. The intention of the system is to allow
+users or developers to specify tighter permission grants (as they are
+added in new Flatpak versions) while fallback to older grants for
+backwards compatibility at run time.
+
+.. note::
+
+   Older Flatpak versions will fail when encountering unknown
+   commandline options, while unrecognized metadata entries will be
+   silently ignored.
+
+   Flatpak manifests using conditional flags (for example,
+   ``--socket-if=`` etc.) will require Flatpak 1.17.0 or newer to
+   build and attempting to build them with older Flatpak versions will
+   produce an error.
+
+The following flags are available to specify conditional
+permissions in CLI and in Flatpak manifests::
+
+  --socket-if=
+  --device-if=
+  --share-if=
+  --allow-if=
+
+The syntax of all the options are ``--socket-if=PERMISSION:CONDITION``
+and so on where ``PERMISSION`` is the available grants for that flag
+(e.g., those listed for ``--socket=``). Conditions can be negated by
+prefixing with ``!``. The following conditions are supported:
+
+- ``true`` - Always evaluates to true
+- ``false``- Always evaluates to false
+- ``has-input-device`` - True if the Flatpak version supports
+  ``--device=input``
+- ``has-wayland`` - True if the current desktop session supports
+  Wayland
+
+Multiple conditionals can be specified for the same grant, in which
+case the permission is granted if any condition matches. If no
+conditional rule evaluates to ``true``, the grant is denied
+unless it is also unconditionally allowed. Duplicate conditions are
+ignored.
+
+Examples
+`````````
+
+#. The unconditional grant ``--socket=x11`` can be tightened using
+   conditional permissions to ``--socket-if=x11:!has-wayland``. This
+   allows access to X11 only when a Wayland desktop session is not
+   available. To preserve backwards compatibility, the following
+   pattern can be used::
+
+      --socket=x11
+      --socket-if=x11:!has-wayland
+
+   This allows older Flatpak versions which do not understand the
+   conditional permissions function by allowing X11 access always
+   while newer Flatpak, which understands the conditional system will
+   allow X11 access only when the session is not Wayland.
+
+#. If an application requires only access to ``input`` device permission,
+   the following flags can be used to move away from ``--device=all``
+   to ``--device=input``::
+
+      --device=all
+      --device-if=all:!has-input-device
+      --device=input
+
+   This allows older Flatpak versions which do not understand the
+   ``input`` device permission to function by having the broader
+   ``all`` access. Newer Flatpak versions which understand the
+   conditional system (and therefore understands the ``input``
+   permission) will deny ``all`` due to
+   ``--device-if=all:!has-input-device`` and allow only ``input`` due
+   to ``--device=input``.
+
+To explicitly deny a permission that might be granted through runtime
+metadata or overrides ``--nosocket=NAME, --unshare=NAME`` etc. can be
+used::
+
+  --nosocket=x11
+
+This denial can be combined with conditional grants to remove
+unconditional access while allowing conditional access::
+
+  --nosocket=x11
+  --socket=x11
+  --socket-if=x11:!has-wayland
+
+This denies unconditional X11 access but allows X11 conditionally when
+Wayland is unavailable. Older Flatpak versions will see only the final
+``--socket=x11`` grant and allow X11 unconditionally, while newer
+versions recognise the conditional logic and evaluates it at runtime.
+
 .. rubric:: Footnotes
 
 .. [#f1] This is not necessarily required, but without it the X11 shared

docs/under-the-hood.rst

@@ -47,6 +47,85 @@ stored once.
 This `blog post <https://blogs.gnome.org/alexl/2017/10/02/on-application-sizes-and-bloat-in-flatpak/>`_
 explains the underlying structure of a Flatpak repository in more detail.
 
+Conditional permission system
+-----------------------------
+
+Since Flatpak 1.17.0, conditional permissions allow permissions to be
+granted only when certain runtime conditions are satisfied, with
+fallback to unconditional grants for compatibility with older versions.
+
+Permissions are internally represented as:
+
+- unconditionally allowed or denied
+- a reset flag indicating whether the current layer overrides rules
+  from lower layers
+- a set of conditional rules under which the permission may be allowed
+
+For example:
+
+- ``--socket=NAME`` unconditionally allows the permission and resets any
+  previously defined rules for that permission
+- ``--nosocket=NAME`` unconditionally denies the permission and resets
+  any previously defined rules
+- ``--socket-if=NAME:CONDITION`` adds a conditional rule without
+  resetting existing rules
+
+Conditions may be negated using ``!``.
+
+Multiple conditional rules can be specified for the same permission. In
+this case, the permission is granted if any condition evaluates to true.
+
+Duplicate conditions are ignored. The order of conditions does not
+affect evaluation.
+
+If no conditional rules are present, the permission is granted only if
+it is unconditionally allowed.
+
+If conditional rules are present, the permission is granted if any
+condition evaluates to true, and denied otherwise, unless it is also
+unconditionally allowed.
+
+If an unconditional entry follows a conditional entry for the same
+grant in commandline flags, the earlier unconditional entry is treated
+as backwards compatibility fallback and does not affect the final
+permission state. So the following is effectively treated as
+``--socket-if=x11:!has-wayland`` in Flatpak versions supporting
+conditional permissions::
+
+  --socket=x11
+  --socket-if=x11:!has-wayland
+
+Permissions are written to metadata using the following rules:
+
+- Unconditionally allowed permissions are written as ``NAME``
+- Unconditionally denied permissions are written as ``!NAME``
+- Conditionally allowed permissions are written as:
+
+  - unconditional ``NAME`` entry for compat
+  - ``if:NAME:CONDITION`` entries
+
+If the permission resets previously defined rules, an explicit ``!NAME``
+entry is written first, followed by the unconditional ``NAME`` entry and
+then the ``if:NAME:CONDITION`` entries. This is omitted when saving an
+application's own metadata, as opposed to overrides.
+
+When parsing metadata, a non-negated unconditional ``NAME`` entry
+appearing before a ``if:NAME:CONDITION`` entry is treated as a
+compatibility fallback and does not affect the final permission
+state. Eg. ``sockets=x11;if:x11:!has-wayland;`` is effectively treated
+as ``if:x11:!has-wayland`` in Flatpak versions supporting
+conditional permissions.
+
+The ``fallback-x11`` socket, on pre-1.17 Flatpak versions implicitly
+granted ``x11`` access and at runtime X11 access was suppressed when
+Wayland was available, while on newer Flatpak (1.17+) it is internally
+converted to the conditional syntax ``if:x11:!has-wayland``. When saving
+the metadata, Flatpak converts ``if:x11:!has-wayland`` back to
+``fallback-x11`` only when it is the sole conditional on ``x11``. If
+additional conditionals are present, the new syntax is written directly
+and older Flatpak versions will not understand the conditional entries.
+A conditional grant for ``fallback-x11`` is not allowed.
+
 Underlying technologies
 -----------------------