Skip to content
Open
Show file tree
Hide file tree
Changes from all commits
Commits
Show all changes
21 commits
Select commit Hold shift + click to select a range
97472e7
Option 4: Full lock-free architecture with atomics
Jan 29, 2026
bc791f2
Add seqlock for precise memory accounting
Jan 29, 2026
b7e06ec
Combine seqlock runtime optimization with fast initialization
nishitnshah Feb 3, 2026
6b90c20
Option 5: Eliminate file lock with atomic CAS (2.1s init)
nishitnshah Feb 3, 2026
c776b31
Update branch comparison with Option 5 details
nishitnshah Feb 3, 2026
8f31844
Add comprehensive test suite with expected outcomes
nishitnshah Feb 3, 2026
96bb247
Add quick test reference card
nishitnshah Feb 3, 2026
cb475ec
Option 5C: Replace file lock with shared memory semaphore for postInit
nishitnshah Feb 3, 2026
6175a7a
Option 5D: Fix host PID detection race condition and semaphore deadlock
nishitnshah Feb 3, 2026
f34e8e9
Replace fixed 200ms sleep with adaptive polling loop
nishitnshah Feb 3, 2026
3d4a588
Critical fix: Stale semaphore timeouts causing 300s hangs
nishitnshah Feb 3, 2026
1d7b476
Fix stale state from crashed processes using atomic CAS cleanup
nishitnshah Feb 3, 2026
51bf894
Replace complex recovery logic with simple exit cleanup
nishitnshah Feb 3, 2026
a1dfa3d
Fix exit cleanup deadlock: don't release-then-reacquire lock
nishitnshah Feb 3, 2026
a0264ef
Make exit cleanup foolproof: no semaphore needed, atomic operations only
nishitnshah Feb 4, 2026
c6bc83f
Fix slow process slot cleanup holding lock too long
nishitnshah Feb 4, 2026
5124f20
Optimize seqlock and utilization watcher to prevent random 256MB allo…
nishitnshah Feb 4, 2026
154551d
Remove documentation clutter - keep only option 5d specific docs
nishitnshah Feb 4, 2026
89ca1af
Restore documentation of existing implementation and its limitations
nishitnshah Feb 4, 2026
abc0704
Restore test documentation for option 5d
nishitnshah Feb 4, 2026
6fbce1b
Fix missing stdarg.h include in test_comprehensive.cu
nishitnshah Feb 4, 2026
File filter

Filter by extension

Filter by extension

Conversations
Failed to load comments.
Loading
Jump to
Jump to file
Failed to load files.
Loading
Diff view
Diff view
838 changes: 838 additions & 0 deletions EXISTING_MULTIPROCESS_MEMORY_ARCHITECTURE.md

Large diffs are not rendered by default.

450 changes: 450 additions & 0 deletions EXIT_CLEANUP_APPROACH.md

Large diffs are not rendered by default.

479 changes: 479 additions & 0 deletions OPTION5D_FIX_DETECTION_AND_DEADLOCK.md

Large diffs are not rendered by default.

278 changes: 278 additions & 0 deletions QUICK_TEST_REFERENCE.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,278 @@
# Quick Test Reference Card

**Option 5: Atomic CAS + Seqlock**

---

## Run Tests

```bash
./run_comprehensive_tests.sh 8
```

---

## Expected Outcomes (8 Processes)

### ✅ Initialization

| Metric | Expected Value | Meaning |
|--------|----------------|---------|
| **INITIALIZER count** | 1 | Only one process wins CAS |
| **SPIN-WAITER count** | 0-2 | Processes 1-2 may wait briefly |
| **FAST PATH count** | 5-7 | Most processes skip initialization |
| **Total time** | <5 seconds | Fast startup |
| **Initializer time** | ~2000ms | Does full GPU enumeration |
| **Spin-waiter time** | 50-200ms | Waits for initializer |
| **Fast path time** | <50ms | Instant skip |

### ✅ Memory Operations

| Metric | Expected Value | Meaning |
|--------|----------------|---------|
| **Allocation failures** | 0 | No false OOMs |
| **Completed processes** | 8/8 | All finish successfully |
| **Memory accounting** | Within 10% | Accurate tracking |

### ✅ High Contention

| Metric | Expected Value | Meaning |
|--------|----------------|---------|
| **Thread completion** | 100% | No deadlocks |
| **Failure rate** | 0% | All operations succeed |
| **Throughput** | >1000 ops/sec | Excellent performance |

### ✅ Seqlock (Partial Reads)

| Metric | Expected Value | Meaning |
|--------|----------------|---------|
| **Inconsistency rate** | <5% | Seqlock working correctly |
| **Warnings** | 0-20 | Minor inconsistencies acceptable |
| **Failures** | 0 | No major torn reads |

### ✅ Stress Test

| Metric | Expected Value | Meaning |
|--------|----------------|---------|
| **Pass rate** | 18-20/20 | Stable over time |
| **Orphaned processes** | 0 | Clean shutdown |

---

## Visual Guide

### Good Result Example

```
┌──────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│ PHASE 3: Multi-Process Test (8 processes) │
└──────────────────────────────────────────────────────┘

Expected: Exactly 1 process is INITIALIZER (CAS winner)
✓ PASS: Exactly 1 INITIALIZER (atomic CAS working correctly)

Expected: 0-2 processes are SPIN-WAITERs (early arrivals)
✓ PASS: SPIN-WAITER count acceptable: 1

Expected: Remaining processes take FAST PATH (late arrivals)
✓ PASS: Majority took FAST PATH: 6/8

Expected: Initialization completes in <3 seconds
✓ PASS: Total execution time: 2s (expected <5s)

Expected: All allocations succeed (no OOM false positives)
✓ PASS: No allocation failures (0 false OOMs)

Expected: Seqlock retry rate: <1%
✓ PASS: No seqlock warnings (perfect consistency)

Expected: All processes complete without deadlock
✓ PASS: All 8 processes completed (no deadlocks)

Expected: Operations per second: >1000 ops/sec
✓ PASS: Throughput excellent: 1234 ops/sec (>1000 expected)

╔══════════════════════════════════════════════════════╗
║ ║
║ ✓ ALL VALIDATIONS PASSED ║
║ ║
╚══════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
```

### Warning Example (Still Acceptable)

```
⚠ WARN: SPIN-WAITER count: 3 (expected ≤2)
✓ PASS: Majority took FAST PATH: 4/8
⚠ WARN: 12 seqlock warnings (minor inconsistencies under load)
✓ PASS: All 8 processes completed (no deadlocks)
```

**Interpretation**: System under higher load, but still working correctly.

### Failure Example

```
✗ FAIL: Expected 1 INITIALIZER, found 3
```

**Action**: Atomic CAS broken. Check compiler version (need GCC 4.9+).

---

## Timing Cheat Sheet

### Process Initialization Times

```
INITIALIZER: ████████████████████ ~2000ms (Full init)
SPIN-WAITER: ███ ~100ms (Brief wait)
FAST PATH: █ <50ms (Instant skip)
```

### By Process Rank (Typical)

```
Rank 0: ████████████████████ 2000ms (INITIALIZER - First started)
Rank 1: ███ 120ms (SPIN-WAITER - Lost CAS)
Rank 2: ███ 115ms (SPIN-WAITER - Lost CAS)
Rank 3: █ 35ms (FAST PATH - Late arrival)
Rank 4: █ 28ms (FAST PATH - Late arrival)
Rank 5: █ 22ms (FAST PATH - Late arrival)
Rank 6: █ 18ms (FAST PATH - Late arrival)
Rank 7: █ 15ms (FAST PATH - Late arrival)
```

---

## Quick Validation Checklist

**After running tests, verify:**

- [ ] Compilation succeeded
- [ ] Exactly 1 INITIALIZER found
- [ ] At least 50% processes took FAST PATH
- [ ] Total time <5 seconds
- [ ] 0 allocation failures
- [ ] Seqlock inconsistency rate <5%
- [ ] All processes completed (no deadlock)
- [ ] Throughput >500 ops/sec (>1000 = excellent)
- [ ] Stress test pass rate ≥18/20

**If all checked**: Option 5 is working correctly! ✅

---

## Interpreting the Role Distribution

### Perfect Distribution (Rank = Launch Order)

```
Process Rank 0: INITIALIZER ← First to start, wins CAS
Process Rank 1: SPIN-WAITER ← Second, loses CAS, waits
Process Rank 2: FAST PATH ← Third, arrives late
Process Rank 3: FAST PATH ← Fourth, arrives late
Process Rank 4: FAST PATH ← Fifth, arrives late
Process Rank 5: FAST PATH ← Sixth, arrives late
Process Rank 6: FAST PATH ← Seventh, arrives late
Process Rank 7: FAST PATH ← Eighth, arrives late
```

**Why this is good**: Test script staggers starts (rank × 10ms), so later ranks should take fast path.

### Good Distribution (Some Variation)

```
1 INITIALIZER ← One process did initialization
2 SPIN-WAITERs ← Two processes arrived early, waited
5 FAST PATHs ← Five processes arrived late, skipped
```

**Why this is acceptable**: System timing variations are normal.

### Bad Distribution (Fast Path Not Working)

```
1 INITIALIZER
7 SPIN-WAITERs ← Everyone waiting! Fast path broken!
0 FAST PATHs
```

**Action**: Check atomic read implementation in fast path check.

---

## Performance Thresholds

### Initialization Time (8 processes)

| Time | Grade | Status |
|------|-------|--------|
| <3s | A+ | Excellent - Optimal performance |
| 3-5s | A | Good - Expected performance |
| 5-8s | B | Acceptable - Some contention |
| 8-12s | C | Slow - Investigate contention |
| >12s | F | Failure - Fast path not working |

### Throughput (ops/sec)

| Rate | Grade | Status |
|------|-------|--------|
| >1500 | A+ | Excellent - Minimal contention |
| 1000-1500 | A | Good - Expected performance |
| 500-1000 | B | Acceptable - Moderate contention |
| 200-500 | C | Slow - High contention |
| <200 | F | Failure - Serialization issues |

### Seqlock Inconsistency Rate

| Rate | Grade | Status |
|------|-------|--------|
| 0% | A+ | Perfect - No retries needed |
| <1% | A | Excellent - Rare retries |
| 1-5% | B | Good - Acceptable retries |
| 5-10% | C | High - Investigate load |
| >10% | F | Failure - Torn reads occurring |

---

## Troubleshooting Quick Guide

| Symptom | Likely Cause | Quick Fix |
|---------|--------------|-----------|
| Multiple INITIALIZERs | Atomic CAS broken | Check GCC ≥4.9, verify C11 support |
| No FAST PATH | Staggering not working | Check test script delays |
| Allocation failures | Memory limit too low | Increase `CUDA_DEVICE_MEMORY_LIMIT` |
| High inconsistency | Too much contention | Run with fewer processes |
| Deadlock | Semaphore issue | Check semaphore timeout logs |
| Compilation error | Missing atomics | Install GCC 4.9+ or Clang 3.1+ |

---

## Log File Locations

After test run, logs saved to `/tmp/hami_comprehensive_[timestamp]/`:

```
compile.log - Compilation output
single_process.log - Single process test
multi_process.log - Main multi-process test
stress_test.log - Stress test iterations
init_times.txt - Extracted initialization times
results_summary.txt - Final summary
```

---

## One-Line Validation

```bash
# Quick pass/fail check
./run_comprehensive_tests.sh 8 && echo "✅ PASS" || echo "❌ FAIL"
```

---

**Keep this card handy when running tests!**

For detailed explanations, see `TEST_SUITE_DOCUMENTATION.md`
Loading