Add new style manager to JFB

[MjHead]

https://github.com/Crocoblock/issues-tracker/issues/18154

[github-actions]

🤖 AI PR Review

Risk level: medium

Review

This PR adds a new style manager to JetFormBuilder, integrating the Crocoblock style manager framework into various blocks.

Positive aspects:

• The addition of the style manager follows the Crocoblock architecture and integrates well with existing block types via registering block support.
• The code introduces new React components for the controls UI with proper JSX structure and clean component hierarchy.
• Proper WordPress coding standards are followed for PHP and JavaScript code where applicable.
• Localization functions are preserved and handled appropriately.

Potential issues and suggestions:

• The PR lacks a description, making it difficult to understand the intent without reading through the code. It would benefit from a clear explanation of the new style manager, how it can be used, and implications.
• While many files update labels from "Background Color" to simply "Background" consistently, verify this change doesn't break translations or third-party integrations relying on the exact label.
• The new style manager classes and React components introduced don't appear to have associated unit or integration tests. Adding tests for the style manager controls and registration code is recommended to ensure stability.
• The initialization in the block base class was changed: a new hook 'jet-form-builder/styles/register-block' is used to initialize style manager per block, which is a good approach, but ensure backward compatibility and no interference with existing block registration.
• No changes seem to affect security-sensitive code or form processing flows.
• Performance impact appears minimal, as this is UI related code and uses lazy initialization.
• Given this integrates with JetStyleManager which is an optional dependency, ensure that the plugin fails gracefully if the style manager plugin is absent.

Overall: The PR appears well-structured and follows the Crocoblock standards and best practices. It introduces a significant new feature (style manager integration) with good modularity, but would benefit from added tests and documentation.

Files noteworthy for review:

• includes/blocks/types/base.php for the hooked initialization of the style manager per block.
• modules/jet-style/framework/blocks-style-manager/assets/src/components/ for new React components.
• Multiple compatibility files where label changes were made.
• Assets build files for new editor styles and scripts.

No blockers found; recommend merging after adding documentation and tests.

Suggested changelog entry

- ADD: Introduced new style manager integration for form blocks, enabling Crocoblock style controls in JetFormBuilder editor UI.

[github-actions]

🤖 AI PR Review

Risk level: medium

Review

This PR introduces a new style manager module to the JetFormBuilder plugin, including new editor assets, CSS, and React components for controls and tabs, and integrates the style manager with the Block types.

Security & Compliance:

• No obvious security concerns from the PHP and JavaScript code.
• No changes to processing of user input or form submissions.

Performance & Scalability:

• The style manager uses React components and hooks, following WordPress modern best practices.
• No immediate performance issues seen; however, added JS components should be tested for impact on editor load.

Backward Compatibility:

• There are no breaking changes to public APIs or form schemas.
• Existing block registration now adds a hook to setup style manager support.
• The color labels are changed from "Background Color" to "Background" in multiple places, which is a minor UI wording improvement.

General Observations:

• The PR moves style manager registration to a hook, improving extensibility.
• The style manager components are well-structured and consistent with expected design patterns.
• The CSS appears scoped and clean, uses CSS variables.
• The new style manager integration calls are guarded by JetStyleManager compatibility checks.

Missing Considerations:

• There are no added tests for this new style manager, or tests demonstrating its usage and integration.
• Consider adding PHP and JavaScript unit or integration tests to cover the new style manager functionality.

Recommendation:

• Approve for merging after confirming no styling or editor load regressions in testing.
• Suggest adding tests on a follow-up PR to cover new UI components and style application logic.

Suggested changelog entry

- ADD: Introduce new style manager module to JetFormBuilder with UI controls, React components, and block integration for advanced styling capabilities.

[Copilot]

Copilot encountered an error and was unable to review this pull request. You can try again by re-requesting a review.

[github-actions]

🤖 AI PR Review

Risk level: medium

Review

This PR introduces the new style manager integration into JetFormBuilder blocks. The key changes include:

• Added new CSS and JS assets for the Crocoblock Style Manager (CSM) framework.
• Modified several block type classes to support style manager registration and control management.
• Adjusted CSS labels from 'Background color' to the more general 'Background' for better UX and consistency.
• Added a new event hook in Blocks_Repository_Base for hooking block installations.
• Refactored the Base block type to utilize the style manager proxy system, ensuring style controls are properly registered.
• Added React components for controls popover and tabs navigation for the style manager UI.
• Updated the frontend captcha asset due to a minor version change.

Security:

• No direct impact on security; standard WordPress coding practices are followed.

Performance:

• Initialization of style manager through a proxy should be efficient and reusable.
• No heavyweight operations introduced in render or block registration.

Backward Compatibility:

• This PR adds new features and UI improvements without breaking existing public APIs.
• Style settings should not affect current forms without enabling the style manager.

Testing:

• This change touches core block handling and adds UI elements, but there is no evidence of added automated tests for the style manager.
• Recommend adding unit/integration tests for the style manager controls and initializing the proxy, as well as manual testing of block style editing and UI.

Overall, this PR cleanly integrates the new style manager system into JetFormBuilder with no obvious issues. It adheres to WordPress coding standards and should improve styling capabilities in the block editor UI.

Suggest to approve after verifying UI in editor for block styling and confirming no regressions in existing block styling behavior.

Files of interest include:

• includes/blocks/types/base.php (style manager initialization)
• includes/blocks/blocks-repository-base.php (block installation hook)
• modules/jet-style/framework/blocks-style-manager/**/* (new style manager framework assets and components)
• compatibility/* (consistency label changes)
• assets/build/editor/form.builder.* (editor asset version bumps)
• modules/captcha/assets/build/friendly.captcha/frontend.* (updated frontend assets)

Minor:

• The new hook 'jet-form-builder/block-type/before-intall' has a typo: "intall" should be "install". Please correct to avoid confusion.

Suggested changelog entry

- ADD: Integrated new style manager to JetFormBuilder blocks for enhanced styling control in the editor UI.

[github-actions]

🤖 AI PR Review

Risk level: medium

Review

This PR introduces a new style manager to JetFormBuilder, modifying quite a wide range of files to enable centralized styling control for form blocks and components using a style manager framework. There are many renames of labels from 'Background color' to 'Background' throughout compatibility files for Elementor, Bricks, and Jet Style Manager blocks to conform to a consistent UX. The style manager is implemented with React components and hooks as part of the Jet Style framework, including a new added set of styles and controls (modules/jet-style/framework/blocks-style-manager/).

Key points:

• The style manager initialization has been refactored to take an external style manager object instance instead of creating it inside blocks. This aligns with good dependency injection practice.
• The CSS selectors for styling have been cleaned up to use proper namespacing and are adjusted for better CSS targeting (e.g., .selector_no_space).
• The new style controls include interactive features like popover color pickers, typography controls, border, and dimension controls that integrate tightly with WordPress block editor components.
• The Friendly Captcha module has been updated, but it appears to be unrelated to the style manager additions and mostly involves an updated compiled frontend asset JavaScript.
• General code style follows WordPress coding standards, and localization strings use correct escaping.

Concerns/Recommendations:

• Due to such a sweeping change in style handling, ensure thorough backwards compatibility testing, especially for existing saved forms and their style configurations, to prevent regressions.
• Test multi-device and responsive styling as the style manager applies styles depending on preview device types.
• Verify all style controls properly sanitize and escape values to avoid CSS injection risks.
• The style manager integration should be tested extensively with multisite and multilingual environments.
• It would be beneficial to have some automated tests covering the style manager UI controls and CSS generation to avoid regressions.

Overall, the implementation seems well-structured and aligns with current WordPress block editor APIs. The added style manager will vastly improve the UX for styling form blocks in JetFormBuilder.

Specific files of interest include:

• includes/blocks/types/base.php for style manager initialization change.
• modules/jet-style/framework/blocks-style-manager/assets/* for new style manager assets.
• compatibility/elementor/widgets/form.php and others for label text consistency.

Without the full context or runtime testing results, no immediate security issues stand out. Please ensure testing before merge and request QA review for multi-environment coverage.

Suggested changelog entry

- ADD: Introduced new style manager framework for JetFormBuilder blocks to provide centralized styling controls and improved UX for block styling.

[github-actions]

🤖 AI PR Review

Risk level: medium

Review

This PR implements a new style manager to JetFormBuilder (JFB), which involves adding new CSS/JS assets and modifications primarily renaming 'Background Color' labels to 'Background' across multiple integration compatibility files for Bricks, Elementor, Jet Style Manager, and core block types. It also adjusts some internal style manager methods and initializations, improving the modularity and maintainability of style controls.

Security: No direct security risks were found. The changes are mainly UI/UX and integration improvements.

Performance: No performance regressions detected. The style manager uses React and WordPress components properly and adds lightweight CSS.

Backward Compatibility: Label changes from "Background Color" to "Background" should be safe for existing users as it's non-breaking and improves UX clarity. However, consumers integrating with these controls might note the label changes.

Multisite & Scalability: No impact detected.

Testing: The PR lacks specific tests for the new style manager UI components or integration behaviors. Given the scope, adding automated tests for style controls and block style registration would be beneficial.

The asset version files update indicates a successful rebuild.

Specific files to note:

• includes/blocks/types/base.php: Changed maybe_init_style_manager signature and logic. This requires coordinated hook or dependency injection where the style manager instance is passed.
• includes/blocks/modules/general-style.php and multiple compatibility files: Updated CSS selectors and labels to 'Background' for accessibility and clarity.
• modules/jet-style/framework/blocks-style-manager/: Added the new style manager implementation in assets.

Overall, this is a positive enhancement aligning with JetFormBuilder's modular architecture, improving style customization UX without regressions.

Recommendations:

• Add unit or integration tests for the new style manager registration and style controls.

• Ensure documentation updates reflect label changes and new style manager usage.

• IMPROVE: Introduce a new style manager with updated background control labels and enhanced style control UI in JetFormBuilder and its integrations.

Suggested changelog entry

- IMPROVE: Introduce new style manager with refined background controls and updated UI integration across JetFormBuilder and compatibility layers.

[github-actions]

🤖 AI PR Review

Risk level: medium

Review

This PR primarily introduces a new style manager integration to JetFormBuilder and updates numerous label strings from "Background Color" to a simpler "Background" across various compatibility layers (Elementor, Bricks, Jet Style Manager blocks).

Strengths:

• The rename of style control labels from 'Background Color' to 'Background' is consistent and likely improves UI clarity.
• The style manager integration appears to be implemented in a backward-compatible way. The new maybe_init_style_manager method now accepts the style manager instance instead of initializing it internally, which improves flexibility.
• For blocks that do not use the style manager, empty implementations are added which should prevent issues.
• CSS scheme selectors have been cleaned up, removing redundant repeated class names and replaced with simpler selectors, which should improve maintainability.
• The FieldWrapper React component now appends a unique class from attributes.crocoblock_styles._uniqueClassName if it exists, facilitating style targeting by the style manager.

Potential Risks and Items to Double Check:

• The injection of the style manager proxy into blocks relies on passing a style manager object externally. Review how this is integrated to ensure all blocks actually receive it correctly, especially block registration workflows in includes/blocks/types/base.php.
• Style selector changes may affect existing user customizations or third-party extensions relying on the old complex selectors, although these seem to be cleaned rather than broken.
• The Friendly Captcha JS update includes a full minified script replacement. While this code is third-party, it's important to ensure it matches the latest stable version and no unexpected regressions occur.

Testing:

• Verify that styles configured via the style manager correctly apply to blocks.
• Test compatibility in Gutenberg editor, as well as with Elementor and Bricks integrations.
• Confirm no regressions in UI controls due to label renames.
• Test Friendly Captcha functionality thoroughly.

Overall, the PR looks well-structured and follows WordPress coding standards. It primarily focuses on style management enhancements with minimal impact on core form functionality.

I recommend merging after verifying the style manager integration is correctly wired and testing the CAPTCHA changes, with at least basic sanity checks on block UIs and style controls.

Suggested changelog entry

- IMPROVE: Integrate new style manager for blocks with consistent 'Background' label across compatibility layers (Elementor, Bricks, Jet Style Manager) and update CSS selectors for cleaner targeting.