Skip to content

fix(ast lowerer): ARK-353, load arguments in tail calls by value and not by ref#668

Merged
SuperFola merged 1 commit intodevfrom
fix/tail-call-args
Mar 28, 2026
Merged

fix(ast lowerer): ARK-353, load arguments in tail calls by value and not by ref#668
SuperFola merged 1 commit intodevfrom
fix/tail-call-args

Conversation

@SuperFola
Copy link
Copy Markdown
Member

Description

(let f(fun(a b)(if a {(print a" "b) (f b (- a 1))})))
(f 9 9)

works, but replacing b with {b} or (or 0 b) breaks, as it uses a LOAD_FAST_BY_INDEX instead of a LOAD_SYMBOL. This PR fixes this behavior inside tail calls to use LOAD_SYMBOL.

Checklist

  • I have read the Contributor guide
  • My code follows the style guidelines of this project
  • I have commented my code, particularly in hard-to-understand areas
  • I have updated the documentation if needed (on https://github.com/ArkScript-lang/website, content/docs/)
  • I have added tests that prove my fix/feature is working
  • New and existing tests pass locally with my changes

@github-actions
Copy link
Copy Markdown

Static analysis report

Lizard report

Listing only functions with cyclomatic complexity >= 15 or NLOC >= 100 or parameters >= 6.

Filename Start line:end line Function name Parameters NLOC CCN
src/arkreactor/Compiler/Lowerer/ASTLowerer.cpp 355:434 Ark::internal::ASTLowerer::compileListInstruction 3 64 32
src/arkreactor/Compiler/Lowerer/ASTLowerer.cpp 845:991 Ark::internal::ASTLowerer::handleFunctionCall 3 114 30
src/arkreactor/Compiler/Lowerer/ASTLowerer.cpp 212:317 Ark::internal::ASTLowerer::compileExpression 5 88 29
src/arkreactor/Compiler/Lowerer/ASTLowerer.cpp 791:843 Ark::internal::ASTLowerer::handleOperator 3 42 18
src/arkreactor/Compiler/Lowerer/ASTLowerer.cpp 107:129 Ark::internal::ASTLowerer::nodeProducesOutput 1 18 17
src/arkreactor/Compiler/Lowerer/ASTLowerer.cpp 589:637 Ark::internal::ASTLowerer::compileLetMutSet 4 40 17
src/arkreactor/Compiler/Lowerer/ASTLowerer.cpp 506:587 Ark::internal::ASTLowerer::compileFunction 3 59 16
Report about files you didn't modify in this PR
Filename Start line:end line Function name Parameters NLOC CCN
src/arkreactor/VM/VM.cpp 407:2156 Ark::VM::safeRun 3 1471 288
src/arkreactor/Compiler/Macros/Processor.cpp 259:634 Ark::internal::MacroProcessor::evaluate 3 344 115
src/arkreactor/Compiler/BytecodeReader.cpp 297:726 Ark::BytecodeReader::display 4 380 114
src/arkreactor/Error/Diagnostics.cpp 45:192 Ark::Diagnostics::makeContext 4 109 44
src/arkscript/main.cpp 24:383 main 2 310 43
src/arkscript/JsonCompiler.cpp 27:276 JsonCompiler::_compile 1 214 38
src/arkreactor/Compiler/NameResolution/NameResolutionPass.cpp 162:267 Ark::internal::NameResolutionPass::visitKeyword 3 85 35
src/arkreactor/Builtins/Slice.cpp 21:93 Ark::internal::Builtins::slice 1 63 34
src/arkreactor/Compiler/AST/Parser.cpp 841:932 Ark::internal::Parser::string 1 88 32
src/arkreactor/Compiler/AST/Node.cpp 179:285 Ark::internal::Node::repr 0 90 30
src/arkreactor/Compiler/Macros/Processor.cpp 107:191 Ark::internal::MacroProcessor::processNode 3 63 28
src/arkreactor/Compiler/AST/Node.cpp 287:368 Ark::internal::Node::debugPrint 1 70 26
src/arkreactor/TypeChecker.cpp 149:236 Ark::types::generateError 6 75 25
src/arkreactor/TypeChecker.cpp 32:147 Ark::types::displayContract 6 102 24
src/arkreactor/Compiler/AST/Parser.cpp 289:417 Ark::internal::Parser::import_ 1 98 23
src/arkreactor/Compiler/NameResolution/NameResolutionPass.cpp 56:160 Ark::internal::NameResolutionPass::visit 2 83 23
include/utf8.hpp 138:184 utf8::isValid 1 44 21
src/arkreactor/VM/Value/Value.cpp 77:145 Ark::Value::toString 2 54 21
src/arkreactor/VM/VM.cpp 2310:2404 Ark::VM::backtrace 3 81 20
src/arkreactor/Compiler/AST/Optimizer.cpp 35:85 Ark::internal::Optimizer::countAndPruneDeadCode 1 42 20
src/arkreactor/VM/Debugger.cpp 251:327 Ark::internal::Debugger::prompt 4 70 19
src/arkreactor/Compiler/NameResolution/StaticScope.cpp 68:109 Ark::internal::NamespaceScope::get 3 32 19
src/arkscript/Formatter.cpp 501:560 Formatter::formatCall 2 51 19
src/arkreactor/Compiler/AST/Optimizer.cpp 87:144 Ark::internal::Optimizer::pruneUnusedGlobalVariables 1 50 18
src/arkreactor/Builtins/String.cpp 46:112 fmt::formatter::parse 1 59 18
src/arkscript/Formatter.cpp 186:248 Formatter::format 3 59 18
src/arkreactor/Compiler/Macros/Executors/Function.cpp 16:89 Ark::internal::FunctionExecutor::applyMacro 2 56 17
include/Ark/Compiler/AST/Predicates.hpp 132:156 Ark::internal::IsSymbol::operator ( ) 1 24 16
src/arkscript/Formatter.cpp 298:339 Formatter::formatFunction 2 35 16
src/arkreactor/VM/VM.cpp 2168:2225 Ark::VM::throwArityError 4 47 15
src/arkreactor/Compiler/Macros/Executors/Function.cpp 99:156 Ark::internal::FunctionExecutor::unify 5 50 15
src/arkreactor/Compiler/IntermediateRepresentation/IROptimizer.cpp 22:260 Ark::internal::IROptimizer::IROptimizer 1 219 14
src/arkreactor/Error/Diagnostics.cpp 194:211 Ark::Diagnostics::helper 7 17 2

CppCheck report

Filename Line Type Description
src/arkreactor/Compiler/Lowerer/ASTLowerer.cpp 612 style Consider using std::count_if algorithm instead of a raw loop.
Report files about files you didn't modify in this PR
Filename Line Type Description
include/Ark/VM/VM.inl 258 style Variable 'maybe_value_ptr' can be declared as pointer to const
src/arkreactor/Builtins/Bytecode.cpp 23 style Parameter 'vm' can be declared as pointer to const
src/arkreactor/Builtins/IO.cpp 165 style Consider using std::transform algorithm instead of a raw loop.
src/arkreactor/Compiler/BytecodeReader.cpp 478 style struct member 'Arg::kind' is never used.
src/arkreactor/Compiler/IntermediateRepresentation/IROptimizer.cpp 249 style Consider using std::transform algorithm instead of a raw loop.
src/arkreactor/Compiler/IntermediateRepresentation/IROptimizer.cpp 256 style Consider using std::transform algorithm instead of a raw loop.
src/arkreactor/Compiler/NameResolution/ScopeResolver.cpp 134 style Consider using std::find_if algorithm instead of a raw loop.
src/arkreactor/VM/VM.cpp 281 error Iterators of different containers 'm_execution_contexts.emplace_back(std::make_unique())' and 'm_execution_contexts.front()' are used together.
include/Ark/VM/Value/Future.hpp 50 style Unused private function: 'Future::deleteSelfViaVM'
src/arkreactor/VM/Value/Future.cpp 23 performance Variable 'm_value' is assigned in constructor body. Consider performing initialization in initialization list.

@github-actions
Copy link
Copy Markdown

Super Instructions report

Some Super Instructions are under the usage threshold (16).

Super Instruction Uses in compiled code
INCREMENT_BY_INDEX 15
INCREMENT 15
STORE_FROM 14
LT_CONST_JUMP_IF_FALSE 8
NEQ_SYM_JUMP_IF_FALSE 4
SET_VAL_TAIL 4
STORE_HEAD 2
MUL_BY 2
GT_SYM_JUMP_IF_FALSE 2
CHECK_TYPE_OF 2
NEQ_CONST_JUMP_IF_TRUE 2
SET_VAL_TAIL_BY_INDEX 1
SET_VAL_HEAD_BY_INDEX 1
MUL_SET_VAL 1
SET_VAL_HEAD 1
STORE_TAIL 1
Super Instructions over the threshold
Super Instruction Uses in compiled code
CALL_SYMBOL 4316
LOAD_CONST_LOAD_CONST 2520
LOAD_CONST_STORE 2387
LOAD_CONST_SET_VAL 658
CALL_BUILTIN 653
INCREMENT_STORE 520
AT_SYM_SYM 513
GET_FIELD_FROM_SYMBOL_INDEX 486
CALL_BUILTIN_WITHOUT_RETURN_ADDRESS 452
STORE_LIST 362
APPEND_IN_PLACE_SYM 326
LT_LEN_SYM_JUMP_IF_FALSE 296
CALL_SYMBOL_BY_INDEX 291
GET_FIELD_FROM_SYMBOL 279
LT_SYM_JUMP_IF_FALSE 148
EQ_SYM_INDEX_JUMP_IF_TRUE 140
STORE_FROM_INDEX 107
SET_VAL_FROM_INDEX 103
SET_VAL_FROM 94
FUSED_MATH 86
AT_SYM_INDEX_SYM_INDEX 82
STORE_LEN 80
LT_CONST_JUMP_IF_TRUE 75
CALL_CURRENT_PAGE 73
DECREMENT_BY_INDEX 61
EQ_CONST_JUMP_IF_TRUE 48
DECREMENT_STORE 45
GT_CONST_JUMP_IF_TRUE 45
AT_SYM_INDEX_CONST 43
GT_CONST_JUMP_IF_FALSE 39
MUL_BY_INDEX 37
STORE_HEAD_BY_INDEX 35
STORE_TAIL_BY_INDEX 34
CHECK_TYPE_OF_BY_INDEX 27
APPEND_IN_PLACE_SYM_INDEX 22
DECREMENT 18

@coveralls
Copy link
Copy Markdown

Pull Request Test Coverage Report for Build 23689880602

Details

  • 33 of 33 (100.0%) changed or added relevant lines in 1 file are covered.
  • No unchanged relevant lines lost coverage.
  • Overall coverage increased (+0.003%) to 93.758%

Totals Coverage Status
Change from base Build 23607845768: 0.003%
Covered Lines: 9704
Relevant Lines: 10350

💛 - Coveralls

@github-actions
Copy link
Copy Markdown

Fuzzing report

/usr/local/bin/afl-whatsup status check tool for afl-fuzz by Michal Zalewski

Summary stats

    Fuzzers alive : 0
   Dead or remote : 1 (included in stats)
   Total run time : 5 minutes, 0 seconds
      Total execs : 31 thousands
 Cumulative speed : 104 execs/sec
    Pending items : 157 faves, 1291 total
 Coverage reached : 10.01%
    Crashes saved : 0
      Hangs saved : 0

Cycles without finds : 0
Time without finds : 0

[+] Captured 43902 tuples (map size 243009, highest value 255, total values 481561544) in '/dev/null'.
[+] A coverage of 43902 edges were achieved out of 243072 existing (18.06%) with 1299 input files.

@SuperFola SuperFola merged commit b308ccc into dev Mar 28, 2026
33 checks passed
@SuperFola SuperFola deleted the fix/tail-call-args branch March 28, 2026 17:28
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

2 participants