diff --git a/packages/number-line/src/number-line/index.jsx b/packages/number-line/src/number-line/index.jsx
index fe264a7d85..95290f570c 100644
--- a/packages/number-line/src/number-line/index.jsx
+++ b/packages/number-line/src/number-line/index.jsx
@@ -248,7 +248,8 @@ export class NumberLine extends React.Component {
       });
     };
 
-    let elements = showCorrectAnswer ? getCorrectAnswerElements() : getAnswerElements();
+    // Determine which elements to show on the chart
+    let elements = showCorrectAnswer && correctResponse ? getCorrectAnswerElements() : getAnswerElements();
 
     let maxPointsMessage = () =>
       maxNumberOfPoints == 1