diff --git a/shared/config/core-lockdown.json b/shared/config/core-lockdown.json deleted file mode 100644 index 126719fc..00000000 --- a/shared/config/core-lockdown.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,8 +0,0 @@ -{ - "_meta": { - "status": "DEPRECATED", - "note": "SSOT moved to shared/lockdown/lockdown.json. This file is a compat stub.", - "ssot": "shared/lockdown/lockdown.json", - "deprecated_since": "2026-04-12" - } -} diff --git a/shared/discovery/_v94_new_nodes.json b/shared/discovery/_v94_new_nodes.json deleted file mode 100644 index d48c709b..00000000 --- a/shared/discovery/_v94_new_nodes.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,2903 +0,0 @@ -[ - { - "id": "L6-geo-v94-silica-felsic-min", - "level": "L6_geology", - "claim": "규장질 암석 SiO2 최소", - "measured": 66, - "unit": "wt%", - "detail": "화강암/류올라이트 기준", - "source": "Le Bas & Streckeisen 1991 IUGS", - "source_url": "https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01160698", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "66 = 11*n", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "66 = 11*n", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "EMPIRICAL", - "thread": "n", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [ - "BT-94" - ] - }, - { - "id": "L6-geo-v94-earth-layers-count", - "level": "L6_geology", - "claim": "지구 층 수(PREM 기준)", - "measured": 4, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "내핵/외핵/맨틀/지각", - "source": "PREM Dziewonski & Anderson 1981", - "source_url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/0031-9201(81)90046-7", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "4 = tau", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "4 = tau", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "tau", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [ - "BT-94" - ] - }, - { - "id": "L6-geo-v94-continents", - "level": "L6_geology", - "claim": "대륙 수(7대륙설 제외 6대륙)", - "measured": 6, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "아프리카/남미/북미/아시아/유럽/호주(올림픽 링 6대륙)", - "source": "National Geographic / Olympic Charter", - "source_url": "https://www.nationalgeographic.org", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "6 = n", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "6 = n", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "CONVENTION", - "thread": "n", - "origin": "convention", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-geo-v94-major-oceans", - "level": "L6_geology", - "claim": "주요 해양 수", - "measured": 5, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "태평양/대서양/인도양/남빙양/북빙양", - "source": "IHO Publication 23 2021", - "source_url": "https://www.iho.int/uploads/user/pubs/sp/S-23_Ed4_EN.pdf", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "5 = sopfr", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "5 = sopfr", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "CONVENTION", - "thread": "sopfr", - "origin": "convention", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-geo-v94-richter-each-10x", - "level": "L6_geology", - "claim": "리히터 1단계당 진폭 배율", - "measured": 10, - "unit": "배", - "detail": "로그 스케일 정의", - "source": "Richter 1935 BSSA", - "source_url": "https://doi.org/10.1785/BSSA0250020001", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "10 = n+tau", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "10 = n+tau", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "n", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [ - "BT-94" - ] - }, - { - "id": "L6-geo-v94-vei-steps", - "level": "L6_geology", - "claim": "화산폭발지수 VEI 단계 수", - "measured": 8, - "unit": "단계", - "detail": "VEI 0~7", - "source": "Newhall & Self 1982 JGR", - "source_url": "https://doi.org/10.1029/JC087iC13p11231", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "8 = sigma-tau", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "8 = sigma-tau", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "sigma", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [ - "BT-94" - ] - }, - { - "id": "L6-geo-v94-pwave-mantle", - "level": "L6_geology", - "claim": "맨틀 하부 P파 평균 속도", - "measured": 12, - "unit": "km/s", - "detail": "PREM 670 km 이하 약 12 km/s", - "source": "Dziewonski & Anderson 1981", - "source_url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/0031-9201(81)90046-7", - "uncertainty": 1, - "n6_expr": "12 = sigma", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "12 = sigma", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "EMPIRICAL", - "thread": "sigma", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [ - "BT-94" - ] - }, - { - "id": "L6-geo-v94-geologic-time-units", - "level": "L6_geology", - "claim": "지질 시간 단위 계층 수", - "measured": 4, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "이언/대/기/세", - "source": "ICS 2023 Timescale", - "source_url": "https://stratigraphy.org/icschart/ChronostratChart2023-09.pdf", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "4 = tau", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "4 = tau", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "tau", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [ - "BT-94" - ] - }, - { - "id": "L6-geo-v94-hadean-end", - "level": "L6_geology", - "claim": "명왕누대 종료", - "measured": 4.0, - "unit": "Ga", - "detail": "40억 년 전", - "source": "ICS 2023", - "source_url": "https://stratigraphy.org", - "uncertainty": 0.05, - "n6_expr": "4 = tau (Ga)", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "4 = tau (Ga)", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "EMPIRICAL", - "thread": "tau", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-geo-v94-mantle-peridotite-olivine", - "level": "L6_geology", - "claim": "맨틀 감람암 중 감람석 비율", - "measured": 60, - "unit": "vol%", - "detail": "상부맨틀 전형", - "source": "McDonough & Sun 1995", - "source_url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/0009-2541(94)00140-4", - "uncertainty": 5, - "n6_expr": "60 = n*(n+tau)", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "60 = n*(n+tau)", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "EMPIRICAL", - "thread": "n", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-geo-v94-fault-types", - "level": "L6_geology", - "claim": "단층 주요 유형 수", - "measured": 3, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "정단층/역단층/주향이동", - "source": "USGS Earthquake Glossary", - "source_url": "https://earthquake.usgs.gov/learn/glossary/?term=fault", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "3 = n/phi", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "3 = n/phi", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "phi", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-geo-v94-fold-types", - "level": "L6_geology", - "claim": "습곡 주요 유형 수", - "measured": 2, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "배사/향사", - "source": "Davis & Reynolds 1996", - "source_url": "https://www.wiley.com", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "2 = phi", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "2 = phi", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "phi", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-geo-v94-magma-types", - "level": "L6_geology", - "claim": "마그마 주요 유형 수", - "measured": 3, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "현무암질/안산암질/유문암질", - "source": "Winter 2010 Igneous Petrology", - "source_url": "https://www.pearson.com", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "3 = n/phi", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "3 = n/phi", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "phi", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-geo-v94-metamorphic-grades", - "level": "L6_geology", - "claim": "변성 등급 수", - "measured": 4, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "저/중/고/초고압 변성", - "source": "Yardley 1989 Metamorphic Petrology", - "source_url": "https://www.blackwell.com", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "4 = tau", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "4 = tau", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "tau", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-geo-v94-soil-texture-usda", - "level": "L6_geology", - "claim": "USDA 토성 삼각 분류 수", - "measured": 12, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "사토~점토 12계층", - "source": "USDA NRCS 2017", - "source_url": "https://www.nrcs.usda.gov", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "12 = sigma", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "12 = sigma", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "CONVENTION", - "thread": "sigma", - "origin": "convention", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-geo-v94-mineral-luster", - "level": "L6_geology", - "claim": "광물 광택 주요 유형 수", - "measured": 6, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "금속/유리/진주/수지/실크/토상", - "source": "Nesse 2012 Introduction to Mineralogy", - "source_url": "https://www.oup.com", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "6 = n", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "6 = n", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "CONVENTION", - "thread": "n", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-geo-v94-diamond-cubic-atoms", - "level": "L6_geology", - "claim": "다이아몬드 단위셀 원자 수", - "measured": 8, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "Fd-3m 단위셀", - "source": "IUCr International Tables A", - "source_url": "https://it.iucr.org", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "8 = sigma-tau", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "8 = sigma-tau", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "sigma", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [ - "BT-208" - ] - }, - { - "id": "L6-geo-v94-halite-nacl-coord", - "level": "L6_geology", - "claim": "할라이트 NaCl 배위수", - "measured": 6, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "Na 주위 Cl 6개", - "source": "Wells 1984 Structural Inorganic Chemistry", - "source_url": "https://www.oup.com", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "6 = n", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "6 = n", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "n", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [ - "BT-208" - ] - }, - { - "id": "L6-geo-v94-calcite-cleavage", - "level": "L6_geology", - "claim": "방해석 벽개 방향 수", - "measured": 3, - "unit": "방향", - "detail": "능면체형 3방향 완전 벽개", - "source": "Nesse 2012", - "source_url": "https://www.oup.com", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "3 = n/phi", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "3 = n/phi", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "phi", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-geo-v94-quartz-prism-faces", - "level": "L6_geology", - "claim": "석영 육각기둥 면 수", - "measured": 6, - "unit": "면", - "detail": "m 면 6개", - "source": "Nesse 2012", - "source_url": "https://www.oup.com", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "6 = n", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "6 = n", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "n", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-geo-v94-tectonic-wilson-cycle", - "level": "L6_geology", - "claim": "윌슨 사이클 단계 수", - "measured": 6, - "unit": "단계", - "detail": "배아→성숙→쇠퇴→잔류→봉합→충돌", - "source": "Wilson 1966 Nature 211", - "source_url": "https://doi.org/10.1038/211676a0", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "6 = n", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "6 = n", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "EMPIRICAL", - "thread": "n", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [ - "BT-94" - ] - }, - { - "id": "L6-geo-v94-continent-crust-density", - "level": "L6_geology", - "claim": "대륙 지각 평균 밀도", - "measured": 2.7, - "unit": "g/cm3", - "detail": "화강암질 중간값", - "source": "Rudnick & Gao 2003 Treatise on Geochemistry", - "source_url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/B0-08-043751-6/03016-4", - "uncertainty": 0.1, - "n6_expr": "2.7 ≈ n/phi-phi/n", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "2.7 ≈ n/phi-phi/n", - "grade": "EMPIRICAL", - "causal": "EMPIRICAL", - "thread": "phi", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-geo-v94-moh-moho-depth-cont", - "level": "L6_geology", - "claim": "대륙 모호면 평균 깊이", - "measured": 36, - "unit": "km", - "detail": "24~60 km 범위 평균값", - "source": "Dziewonski & Anderson 1981", - "source_url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/0031-9201(81)90046-7", - "uncertainty": 6, - "n6_expr": "36 = n*n = n^2", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "36 = n*n = n^2", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "EMPIRICAL", - "thread": "n", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [ - "BT-94" - ] - }, - { - "id": "L6-geo-v94-mineral-hardness-feldspar", - "level": "L6_geology", - "claim": "정장석 모스 경도", - "measured": 6, - "unit": "Mohs", - "detail": "장석 경도", - "source": "Mohs 1812 Treatise on Mineralogy", - "source_url": "https://www.oup.com", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "6 = n", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "6 = n", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "EMPIRICAL", - "thread": "n", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [ - "BT-94" - ] - }, - { - "id": "L6-geo-v94-plate-tectonic-driving-force", - "level": "L6_geology", - "claim": "판 구조 운동 주요 구동력 수", - "measured": 2, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "맨틀 대류 + 판 침강력(slab pull)", - "source": "Forsyth & Uyeda 1975 GJI", - "source_url": "https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-246X.1975.tb00631.x", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "2 = phi", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "2 = phi", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "EMPIRICAL", - "thread": "phi", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-geo-v94-seismic-wave-types", - "level": "L6_geology", - "claim": "지진파 주요 유형 수", - "measured": 4, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "P/S/러브/레일리파", - "source": "Stein & Wysession 2003", - "source_url": "https://www.wiley.com", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "4 = tau", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "4 = tau", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "tau", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-geo-v94-primary-crust-compositions", - "level": "L6_geology", - "claim": "지각 주요 구성 광물 그룹 수", - "measured": 6, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "장석/석영/휘석/감람석/운모/각섬석", - "source": "Rudnick & Gao 2003", - "source_url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/B0-08-043751-6/03016-4", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "6 = n", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "6 = n", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "EMPIRICAL", - "thread": "n", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-geo-v94-mohs-topmost", - "level": "L6_geology", - "claim": "모스 경도 최대값", - "measured": 10, - "unit": "Mohs", - "detail": "다이아몬드 = 10", - "source": "Mohs 1812", - "source_url": "https://www.oup.com", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "10 = n+tau", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "10 = n+tau", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "CONVENTION", - "thread": "n", - "origin": "convention", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-geo-v94-soil-horizons-master", - "level": "L6_geology", - "claim": "마스터 토양 층위 수", - "measured": 6, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "O/A/E/B/C/R", - "source": "USDA NRCS Soil Survey Manual 2017", - "source_url": "https://www.nrcs.usda.gov", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "6 = n", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "6 = n", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "CONVENTION", - "thread": "n", - "origin": "convention", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-geo-v94-ophiolite-layers", - "level": "L6_geology", - "claim": "오피올라이트 표준 층서 수", - "measured": 6, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "퇴적암/베개용암/시트다이크/반려암/맨틀감람암+6번째 변환대", - "source": "Penrose Conference 1972", - "source_url": "https://doi.org/10.1130/penrose.1972", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "6 = n", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "6 = n", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "n", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-met-v94-atmosphere-layers", - "level": "L6_meteorology", - "claim": "대기권 층 수", - "measured": 5, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "대류권/성층권/중간권/열권/외기권", - "source": "NOAA Atmosphere Structure Guide", - "source_url": "https://www.noaa.gov", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "5 = sopfr", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "5 = sopfr", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "sopfr", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [ - "BT-103" - ] - }, - { - "id": "L6-met-v94-tropos-height-midlat", - "level": "L6_meteorology", - "claim": "중위도 대류권 높이", - "measured": 12, - "unit": "km", - "detail": "35~60도 평균", - "source": "WMO-No.8 2021 Guide to Instruments", - "source_url": "https://library.wmo.int/doc_num.php?explnum_id=10618", - "uncertainty": 1, - "n6_expr": "12 = sigma", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "12 = sigma", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "EMPIRICAL", - "thread": "sigma", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [ - "BT-103" - ] - }, - { - "id": "L6-met-v94-moist-adiabatic-lapse", - "level": "L6_meteorology", - "claim": "습윤 단열 감률(MALR) 평균", - "measured": 6, - "unit": "°C/km", - "detail": "수증기 응결열 보정 후 평균", - "source": "Wallace & Hobbs 2006 Atmospheric Science", - "source_url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/C2009-0-00034-8", - "uncertainty": 1, - "n6_expr": "6 = n", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "6 = n", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "EMPIRICAL", - "thread": "n", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [ - "BT-103" - ] - }, - { - "id": "L6-met-v94-global-circ-cells", - "level": "L6_meteorology", - "claim": "전지구 대기 순환 셀 총 수(양반구)", - "measured": 6, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "해들리2+페렐2+극2", - "source": "Palmen & Newton 1969 Atmospheric Circulation Systems", - "source_url": "https://www.sciencedirect.com/book/9780124381506", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "6 = n", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "6 = n", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "n", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [ - "BT-103" - ] - }, - { - "id": "L6-met-v94-tradewind-lat", - "level": "L6_meteorology", - "claim": "무역풍 한계 위도", - "measured": 30, - "unit": "도", - "detail": "30°N/S 아열대 고압대", - "source": "Barry & Carleton 2001 Atmosphere-Ocean Dynamics", - "source_url": "https://www.routledge.com", - "uncertainty": 2, - "n6_expr": "30 = n*sopfr", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "30 = n*sopfr", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "EMPIRICAL", - "thread": "n", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-met-v94-jet-stream-speed", - "level": "L6_meteorology", - "claim": "극 제트류 겨울 코어 속도", - "measured": 60, - "unit": "m/s", - "detail": "대류권 상부 전형값", - "source": "Archer & Caldeira 2008 GRL", - "source_url": "https://doi.org/10.1029/2008GL033614", - "uncertainty": 10, - "n6_expr": "60 = n*(n+tau)", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "60 = n*(n+tau)", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "EMPIRICAL", - "thread": "n", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-met-v94-hurricane-category-max", - "level": "L6_meteorology", - "claim": "사피어-심프슨 허리케인 등급 최대", - "measured": 5, - "unit": "등급", - "detail": "Cat 1~5", - "source": "Simpson & Saffir 1974 NOAA Tech Memo", - "source_url": "https://www.nhc.noaa.gov", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "5 = sopfr", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "5 = sopfr", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "CONVENTION", - "thread": "sopfr", - "origin": "convention", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-met-v94-typhoon-season-months", - "level": "L6_meteorology", - "claim": "북서태평양 태풍 활성 시즌 길이", - "measured": 6, - "unit": "개월", - "detail": "5~10월 메인 시즌", - "source": "RSMC Tokyo Annual Report 2023", - "source_url": "https://www.jma.go.jp/jma/jma-eng/jma-center/rsmc-hp-pub-eg/RSMC_HP.htm", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "6 = n", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "6 = n", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "EMPIRICAL", - "thread": "n", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-met-v94-cloud-genera", - "level": "L6_meteorology", - "claim": "운형(구름 속) 수", - "measured": 10, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "Ci/Cs/Cc/As/Ac/St/Sc/Ns/Cu/Cb", - "source": "WMO International Cloud Atlas 2017", - "source_url": "https://cloudatlas.wmo.int", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "10 = n+tau", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "10 = n+tau", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "CONVENTION", - "thread": "n", - "origin": "convention", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-met-v94-cloud-etages", - "level": "L6_meteorology", - "claim": "구름 층 수(WMO)", - "measured": 3, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "상층/중층/하층", - "source": "WMO International Cloud Atlas 2017", - "source_url": "https://cloudatlas.wmo.int", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "3 = n/phi", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "3 = n/phi", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "CONVENTION", - "thread": "phi", - "origin": "convention", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-met-v94-rain-drop-max", - "level": "L6_meteorology", - "claim": "최대 강수 빗방울 지름", - "measured": 6, - "unit": "mm", - "detail": "6 mm 이상 붕괴", - "source": "Pruppacher & Klett 1997 Microphysics", - "source_url": "https://doi.org/10.1007/978-0-306-48100-0", - "uncertainty": 0.5, - "n6_expr": "6 = n", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "6 = n", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "EMPIRICAL", - "thread": "n", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [ - "BT-103" - ] - }, - { - "id": "L6-met-v94-snowflake-symmetry", - "level": "L6_meteorology", - "claim": "눈결정 회전 대칭 차수", - "measured": 6, - "unit": "차", - "detail": "육방정계 C6v 대칭", - "source": "Nakaya 1954 Snow Crystals", - "source_url": "https://www.uchicago.edu", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "6 = n", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "6 = n", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "n", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [ - "BT-103", - "BT-208" - ] - }, - { - "id": "L6-met-v94-ozone-layer-km", - "level": "L6_meteorology", - "claim": "오존층 최대 농도 고도", - "measured": 24, - "unit": "km", - "detail": "Dobson 단위 극대 고도", - "source": "WMO GAW Report 278 2023", - "source_url": "https://library.wmo.int", - "uncertainty": 2, - "n6_expr": "24 = J2", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "24 = J2", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "EMPIRICAL", - "thread": "J2", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-met-v94-el-nino-period", - "level": "L6_meteorology", - "claim": "엘니뇨 평균 반복 주기", - "measured": 4, - "unit": "년", - "detail": "2~7년 중앙값", - "source": "NOAA CPC ENSO Diagnostics", - "source_url": "https://www.cpc.ncep.noaa.gov", - "uncertainty": 1, - "n6_expr": "4 = tau", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "4 = tau", - "grade": "EMPIRICAL", - "causal": "EMPIRICAL", - "thread": "tau", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-met-v94-monsoon-duration", - "level": "L6_meteorology", - "claim": "아시아 몬순 지속 기간", - "measured": 4, - "unit": "개월", - "detail": "6~9월 4개월", - "source": "IMD Annual Monsoon Report 2023", - "source_url": "https://mausam.imd.gov.in", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "4 = tau", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "4 = tau", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "EMPIRICAL", - "thread": "tau", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-met-v94-tornado-ef-max", - "level": "L6_meteorology", - "claim": "EF 등급 최대", - "measured": 5, - "unit": "EF", - "detail": "EF0~EF5", - "source": "NOAA SPC Enhanced Fujita Scale 2007", - "source_url": "https://www.spc.noaa.gov", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "5 = sopfr", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "5 = sopfr", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "CONVENTION", - "thread": "sopfr", - "origin": "convention", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-met-v94-beaufort-max", - "level": "L6_meteorology", - "claim": "보퍼트 풍력 등급 최대", - "measured": 12, - "unit": "Bft", - "detail": "Bft 0~12", - "source": "Beaufort 1805 Royal Navy", - "source_url": "https://www.metoffice.gov.uk", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "12 = sigma", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "12 = sigma", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "CONVENTION", - "thread": "sigma", - "origin": "convention", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-met-v94-heavy-rain-kma", - "level": "L6_meteorology", - "claim": "한국 기상청 강호우 기준", - "measured": 12, - "unit": "mm/h", - "detail": "시간 강수량 12 mm/h 이상", - "source": "KMA 예보업무지침 2023", - "source_url": "https://www.kma.go.kr", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "12 = sigma", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "12 = sigma", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "CONVENTION", - "thread": "sigma", - "origin": "convention", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-met-v94-hurricane-eye-typ", - "level": "L6_meteorology", - "claim": "허리케인 눈 전형 직경", - "measured": 24, - "unit": "km", - "detail": "20~60 km 범위 전형", - "source": "Willoughby et al. 2006 MWR", - "source_url": "https://doi.org/10.1175/MWR3113.1", - "uncertainty": 6, - "n6_expr": "24 = J2", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "24 = J2", - "grade": "EMPIRICAL", - "causal": "EMPIRICAL", - "thread": "J2", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-met-v94-saffir-wind-cat5", - "level": "L6_meteorology", - "claim": "사피어-심프슨 Cat 5 최저 풍속", - "measured": 157, - "unit": "mph", - "detail": "252 km/h 이상", - "source": "NHC SSHWS 2012", - "source_url": "https://www.nhc.noaa.gov", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "157 ≈ CONVENTION", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "157 ≈ CONVENTION", - "grade": "CONVENTION", - "causal": "CONVENTION", - "thread": "n", - "origin": "convention", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-met-v94-solar-constant", - "level": "L6_meteorology", - "claim": "태양상수(대기 상한)", - "measured": 1361, - "unit": "W/m2", - "detail": "SORCE/TIM 2019", - "source": "Kopp & Lean 2011 GRL", - "source_url": "https://doi.org/10.1029/2010GL045777", - "uncertainty": 1, - "n6_expr": "1361 ≈ EMPIRICAL", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "1361 ≈ EMPIRICAL", - "grade": "EMPIRICAL", - "causal": "EMPIRICAL", - "thread": "n", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-met-v94-hadley-cells", - "level": "L6_meteorology", - "claim": "해들리 셀 수(전지구 총)", - "measured": 2, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "적도 열대 대류 셀 쌍", - "source": "Hadley 1735 Philos Trans", - "source_url": "https://doi.org/10.1098/rstl.1735.0010", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "2 = phi", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "2 = phi", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "phi", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-met-v94-climate-zones-koppen-main", - "level": "L6_meteorology", - "claim": "쾨펜 주요 기후 구분 수", - "measured": 5, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "A/B/C/D/E", - "source": "Köppen 1884 Klimatologie", - "source_url": "https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-642-12755-3", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "5 = sopfr", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "5 = sopfr", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "CONVENTION", - "thread": "sopfr", - "origin": "convention", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-met-v94-dry-adiabatic-lapse", - "level": "L6_meteorology", - "claim": "건조 단열 감률(DALR)", - "measured": 10, - "unit": "°C/km", - "detail": "g/cp 정확히 9.81 ≈ 10", - "source": "Wallace & Hobbs 2006", - "source_url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/C2009-0-00034-8", - "uncertainty": 0.2, - "n6_expr": "10 ≈ n+tau", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "10 ≈ n+tau", - "grade": "EMPIRICAL", - "causal": "EMPIRICAL", - "thread": "n", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-met-v94-milankovitch-cycles-count", - "level": "L6_meteorology", - "claim": "밀란코비치 주기 수", - "measured": 3, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "이심률/기울기/세차", - "source": "Milankovitch 1941", - "source_url": "https://doi.org/10.1007/978-94-017-3755-2", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "3 = n/phi", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "3 = n/phi", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "phi", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-met-v94-standard-atm-layers-count", - "level": "L6_meteorology", - "claim": "표준 대기 ICAO 층 수", - "measured": 4, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "대류권/성층권/중간권/열권", - "source": "ICAO Doc 7488 ISA 1993", - "source_url": "https://www.icao.int", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "4 = tau", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "4 = tau", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "CONVENTION", - "thread": "tau", - "origin": "convention", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-met-v94-pressure-levels-synoptic", - "level": "L6_meteorology", - "claim": "종관 일기도 주요 등압면 수", - "measured": 6, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "850/700/500/300/200/100 hPa", - "source": "WMO BUFR Manual 2023", - "source_url": "https://library.wmo.int", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "6 = n", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "6 = n", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "CONVENTION", - "thread": "n", - "origin": "convention", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-met-v94-sounding-mandatory-levels", - "level": "L6_meteorology", - "claim": "고층기상 관측 의무 등압면 수", - "measured": 12, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "WMO TEMP 보고 의무 레벨", - "source": "WMO-No.306 Manual on Codes 2023", - "source_url": "https://library.wmo.int", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "12 = sigma", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "12 = sigma", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "CONVENTION", - "thread": "sigma", - "origin": "convention", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-met-v94-weather-front-types", - "level": "L6_meteorology", - "claim": "날씨 전선 유형 수", - "measured": 4, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "한랭/온난/폐색/정체", - "source": "Bjerknes 1922 Geofys Publ", - "source_url": "https://www.metno.no", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "4 = tau", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "4 = tau", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "tau", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-met-v94-cloud-classification-height-levels", - "level": "L6_meteorology", - "claim": "구름 분류 고도 기준 층 수", - "measured": 3, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "하층(0~2km)/중층(2~7km)/상층(7km+)", - "source": "WMO Cloud Atlas 2017", - "source_url": "https://cloudatlas.wmo.int", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "3 = n/phi", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "3 = n/phi", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "CONVENTION", - "thread": "phi", - "origin": "convention", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-eco-v94-g6-founding", - "level": "L6_economics", - "claim": "G6 창설국 수", - "measured": 6, - "unit": "개국", - "detail": "1975년 창설: 미/독/프/영/이/일", - "source": "G7 Archival Records 1975", - "source_url": "https://www.g7.utoronto.ca", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "6 = n", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "6 = n", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "CONVENTION", - "thread": "n", - "origin": "convention", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-eco-v94-market-sessions", - "level": "L6_economics", - "claim": "전지구 주요 외환 거래 세션", - "measured": 4, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "런던/뉴욕/도쿄/시드니", - "source": "BIS Triennial Survey 2022", - "source_url": "https://www.bis.org/statistics/rpfx22.htm", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "4 = tau", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "4 = tau", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "CONVENTION", - "thread": "tau", - "origin": "convention", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-eco-v94-quarterly-reports", - "level": "L6_economics", - "claim": "연간 회계 분기 수", - "measured": 4, - "unit": "분기", - "detail": "Q1~Q4", - "source": "SEC EDGAR Filing Rules", - "source_url": "https://www.sec.gov", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "4 = tau", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "4 = tau", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "CONVENTION", - "thread": "tau", - "origin": "convention", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-eco-v94-rule-72", - "level": "L6_economics", - "claim": "72의 법칙 상수", - "measured": 72, - "unit": "무차원", - "detail": "복리 배증 근사: ln2≈0.693", - "source": "Bernoulli 1690; Sigler 2003", - "source_url": "https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-17836-7", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "72 = n*J2/phi = J2*(n/phi)", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "72 = n*J2/phi = J2*(n/phi)", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "sigma", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [ - "BT-208" - ] - }, - { - "id": "L6-eco-v94-central-bank-big6", - "level": "L6_economics", - "claim": "주요 중앙은행 수(빅6)", - "measured": 6, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "Fed/ECB/BOJ/BOE/PBoC/SNB", - "source": "BIS Annual Report 2023", - "source_url": "https://www.bis.org/publ/arpdf/ar2023e.htm", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "6 = n", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "6 = n", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "CONVENTION", - "thread": "n", - "origin": "convention", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-eco-v94-inflation-target", - "level": "L6_economics", - "claim": "주요국 인플레이션 목표", - "measured": 2, - "unit": "%", - "detail": "Fed/ECB/BOJ 공동 목표치", - "source": "Fed Statement 2012", - "source_url": "https://www.federalreserve.gov/newsevents/pressreleases/monetary20120125c.htm", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "2 = phi", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "2 = phi", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "CONVENTION", - "thread": "phi", - "origin": "convention", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-eco-v94-gdp-components", - "level": "L6_economics", - "claim": "GDP 지출 구성 항목 수", - "measured": 4, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "C+I+G+(X-M)", - "source": "Keynes General Theory 1936", - "source_url": "https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-70344-2", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "4 = tau", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "4 = tau", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "tau", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-eco-v94-fisher-equation-terms", - "level": "L6_economics", - "claim": "피셔 방정식 변수 수", - "measured": 3, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "i = r + π", - "source": "Fisher 1930 Theory of Interest", - "source_url": "https://www.econlib.org", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "3 = n/phi", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "3 = n/phi", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "phi", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-eco-v94-money-supply-levels", - "level": "L6_economics", - "claim": "통화량 지표 수(M0~M3)", - "measured": 4, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "M0/M1/M2/M3", - "source": "Federal Reserve H.6 Release", - "source_url": "https://www.federalreserve.gov", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "4 = tau", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "4 = tau", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "CONVENTION", - "thread": "tau", - "origin": "convention", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-eco-v94-fomc-meetings", - "level": "L6_economics", - "claim": "연준 FOMC 연간 정기 회의 수", - "measured": 8, - "unit": "회", - "detail": "연 8회", - "source": "Federal Reserve FOMC Calendar", - "source_url": "https://www.federalreserve.gov/monetarypolicy/fomccalendars.htm", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "8 = sigma-tau", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "8 = sigma-tau", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "CONVENTION", - "thread": "sigma", - "origin": "convention", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-eco-v94-taylor-rule-coeff", - "level": "L6_economics", - "claim": "테일러 준칙 인플레이션 반응 계수", - "measured": 1.5, - "unit": "무차원", - "detail": "원 Taylor 1993 논문 값", - "source": "Taylor 1993 Carnegie-Rochester 39", - "source_url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/0167-2231(93)90009-L", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "1.5 = n/tau", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "1.5 = n/tau", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "EMPIRICAL", - "thread": "n", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-eco-v94-cobb-douglas-factors", - "level": "L6_economics", - "claim": "콥-더글라스 생산함수 요소 수", - "measured": 2, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "K(자본), L(노동)", - "source": "Cobb & Douglas 1928 AER 18", - "source_url": "https://doi.org/10.1257/aer.18.1.139", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "2 = phi", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "2 = phi", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "phi", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-eco-v94-iso-currency-code-length", - "level": "L6_economics", - "claim": "ISO 4217 통화코드 길이", - "measured": 3, - "unit": "문자", - "detail": "USD/EUR/JPY 등", - "source": "ISO 4217:2015", - "source_url": "https://www.iso.org/standard/64758.html", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "3 = n/phi", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "3 = n/phi", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "CONVENTION", - "thread": "phi", - "origin": "convention", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-eco-v94-country-code-length", - "level": "L6_economics", - "claim": "ISO 3166-1 alpha-2 국가코드 길이", - "measured": 2, - "unit": "문자", - "detail": "KR/US/DE", - "source": "ISO 3166-1:2020", - "source_url": "https://www.iso.org/standard/72482.html", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "2 = phi", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "2 = phi", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "CONVENTION", - "thread": "phi", - "origin": "convention", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-eco-v94-snp500-gics-sectors", - "level": "L6_economics", - "claim": "S&P500 GICS 섹터 수", - "measured": 11, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "2023 GICS 11개 섹터", - "source": "MSCI & S&P GICS 2023", - "source_url": "https://www.msci.com/our-solutions/indexes/gics", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "11 = n+sopfr", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "11 = n+sopfr", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "CONVENTION", - "thread": "n", - "origin": "convention", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-eco-v94-black-scholes-inputs", - "level": "L6_economics", - "claim": "블랙-숄즈 주요 입력 변수 수", - "measured": 5, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "S/K/T/r/σ", - "source": "Black & Scholes 1973 JPE 81", - "source_url": "https://doi.org/10.1086/260062", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "5 = sopfr", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "5 = sopfr", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "sopfr", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-eco-v94-efficient-market-forms", - "level": "L6_economics", - "claim": "효율적 시장 가설 형태 수", - "measured": 3, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "약형/준강형/강형", - "source": "Fama 1970 Journal of Finance 25", - "source_url": "https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-6261.1970.tb00518.x", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "3 = n/phi", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "3 = n/phi", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "phi", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-eco-v94-risk-types-basel", - "level": "L6_economics", - "claim": "바젤 기본 금융 위험 유형 수", - "measured": 3, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "시장/신용/운영 리스크", - "source": "BCBS Basel III Framework 2017", - "source_url": "https://www.bis.org/publ/bcbs189.htm", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "3 = n/phi", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "3 = n/phi", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "CONVENTION", - "thread": "phi", - "origin": "convention", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-eco-v94-bond-coupon-freq", - "level": "L6_economics", - "claim": "미국 채권 쿠폰 연간 지급 횟수", - "measured": 2, - "unit": "회", - "detail": "반기별 지급", - "source": "SIFMA Bond Market Fact Book 2023", - "source_url": "https://www.sifma.org", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "2 = phi", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "2 = phi", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "CONVENTION", - "thread": "phi", - "origin": "convention", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-eco-v94-compound-monthly", - "level": "L6_economics", - "claim": "월 복리 연간 기간 수", - "measured": 12, - "unit": "회", - "detail": "월 복리 기준 n=12", - "source": "Brealey Myers Allen Principles 14e", - "source_url": "https://www.mheducation.com", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "12 = sigma", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "12 = sigma", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "CONVENTION", - "thread": "sigma", - "origin": "convention", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-eco-v94-imf-sdr-basket-size", - "level": "L6_economics", - "claim": "IMF SDR 바스켓 통화 수", - "measured": 5, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "USD/EUR/CNY/JPY/GBP", - "source": "IMF SDR Basket Review 2022", - "source_url": "https://www.imf.org/en/About/Factsheets/Sheets/2023/Special-Drawing-Rights-SDR", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "5 = sopfr", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "5 = sopfr", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "CONVENTION", - "thread": "sopfr", - "origin": "convention", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-eco-v94-lorenz-axes", - "level": "L6_economics", - "claim": "로렌츠 곡선 좌표 축 수", - "measured": 2, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "누적 인구 % vs 누적 소득 %", - "source": "Lorenz 1905 PASA 9", - "source_url": "https://doi.org/10.2307/2276207", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "2 = phi", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "2 = phi", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "phi", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-eco-v94-supply-demand-vars", - "level": "L6_economics", - "claim": "공급-수요 균형 핵심 변수 수", - "measured": 2, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "가격(P) + 수량(Q)", - "source": "Marshall 1890 Principles of Economics", - "source_url": "https://www.econlib.org/library/Marshall/marP.html", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "2 = phi", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "2 = phi", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "phi", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-eco-v94-gini-max", - "level": "L6_economics", - "claim": "지니 계수 완전 불평등 상한", - "measured": 1, - "unit": "0~1", - "detail": "G=1 완전 불평등", - "source": "Gini 1912 Variabilità e mutabilità", - "source_url": "https://doi.org/10.2307/2223319", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "1 = MU", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "1 = MU", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "MU", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-eco-v94-pareto-80-20", - "level": "L6_economics", - "claim": "파레토 법칙 상위 소득 집중 비율", - "measured": 80, - "unit": "%", - "detail": "상위 20%가 80% 소득 보유", - "source": "Pareto 1896 Cours d'économie politique", - "source_url": "https://www.econlib.org", - "uncertainty": 5, - "n6_expr": "80 = n*tau*sigma/tau? EMPIRICAL", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "80 = n*tau*sigma/tau? EMPIRICAL", - "grade": "EMPIRICAL", - "causal": "EMPIRICAL", - "thread": "n", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-eco-v94-credit-rating-invest-grades", - "level": "L6_economics", - "claim": "S&P 투자등급 단계 수", - "measured": 10, - "unit": "단계", - "detail": "AAA~BB- 상위 10단계", - "source": "S&P Global Ratings Methodology 2023", - "source_url": "https://www.spglobal.com", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "10 = n+tau", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "10 = n+tau", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "CONVENTION", - "thread": "n", - "origin": "convention", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-eco-v94-fed-reserve-districts", - "level": "L6_economics", - "claim": "미국 연방준비은행 지구 수", - "measured": 12, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "보스턴~샌프란시스코 12지구", - "source": "Federal Reserve System Structure", - "source_url": "https://www.federalreserve.gov/aboutthefed/structure-federal-reserve-districts.htm", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "12 = sigma", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "12 = sigma", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "CONVENTION", - "thread": "sigma", - "origin": "convention", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-eco-v94-ecb-founding-members", - "level": "L6_economics", - "claim": "ECB 창설 시 유로존 회원국", - "measured": 12, - "unit": "개국", - "detail": "1999년 출범 12개국", - "source": "ECB History", - "source_url": "https://www.ecb.europa.eu/ecb/history/emu/html/index.en.html", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "12 = sigma", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "12 = sigma", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "CONVENTION", - "thread": "sigma", - "origin": "convention", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-eco-v94-x-inefficiency-factors", - "level": "L6_economics", - "claim": "X-비효율 요인 유형", - "measured": 3, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "경쟁결여/경영미흡/조직관성", - "source": "Leibenstein 1966 AER 56", - "source_url": "https://doi.org/10.1257/aer.56.3.392", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "3 = n/phi", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "3 = n/phi", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "phi", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-eco-v94-game-theory-players-min", - "level": "L6_economics", - "claim": "최소 게임 이론 플레이어 수", - "measured": 2, - "unit": "명", - "detail": "2인 게임 최소 단위", - "source": "von Neumann & Morgenstern 1944", - "source_url": "https://press.princeton.edu", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "2 = phi", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "2 = phi", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "phi", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-lin-v94-word-order-types", - "level": "L6_linguistics", - "claim": "기본 어순 유형 수", - "measured": 6, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "SOV/SVO/VSO/VOS/OVS/OSV", - "source": "Greenberg 1963 Universals of Language", - "source_url": "https://www.jstor.org/stable/411579", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "6 = n", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "6 = n", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "EMPIRICAL", - "thread": "n", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [ - "BT-208" - ] - }, - { - "id": "L6-lin-v94-ipa-manner-pulmonic", - "level": "L6_linguistics", - "claim": "IPA 조음 방법 수(폐장기류)", - "measured": 8, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "파열/마찰/비음/탄음/전동음/설측/접근음/설측접근음", - "source": "IPA Chart 2015", - "source_url": "https://www.internationalphoneticassociation.org", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "8 = sigma-tau", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "8 = sigma-tau", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "CONVENTION", - "thread": "sigma", - "origin": "convention", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-lin-v94-vowel-height", - "level": "L6_linguistics", - "claim": "IPA 모음 높이 단계", - "measured": 4, - "unit": "단계", - "detail": "고/중고/중저/저", - "source": "IPA Chart 2015", - "source_url": "https://www.internationalphoneticassociation.org", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "4 = tau", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "4 = tau", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "CONVENTION", - "thread": "tau", - "origin": "convention", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-lin-v94-vowel-backness", - "level": "L6_linguistics", - "claim": "IPA 모음 전후 위치", - "measured": 3, - "unit": "위치", - "detail": "전설/중설/후설", - "source": "IPA Chart 2015", - "source_url": "https://www.internationalphoneticassociation.org", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "3 = n/phi", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "3 = n/phi", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "CONVENTION", - "thread": "phi", - "origin": "convention", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-lin-v94-english-consonants-rp", - "level": "L6_linguistics", - "claim": "영어 자음 수(RP 기준)", - "measured": 24, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "IPA 자음 24개", - "source": "Roach 2009 English Phonetics 4e", - "source_url": "https://doi.org/10.1017/9781139381895", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "24 = J2", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "24 = J2", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "EMPIRICAL", - "thread": "J2", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-lin-v94-english-vowel-monoph", - "level": "L6_linguistics", - "claim": "영어 단모음 수(RP 기준)", - "measured": 12, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "IPA 단모음 12개", - "source": "Roach 2009", - "source_url": "https://doi.org/10.1017/9781139381895", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "12 = sigma", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "12 = sigma", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "EMPIRICAL", - "thread": "sigma", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-lin-v94-korean-basic-consonants", - "level": "L6_linguistics", - "claim": "한글 기본 자음 수", - "measured": 14, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "ㄱ~ㅎ 14개", - "source": "훈민정음 1443", - "source_url": "https://www.iksi.or.kr", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "14 = n*phi+phi", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "14 = n*phi+phi", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "phi", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-lin-v94-korean-basic-vowels", - "level": "L6_linguistics", - "claim": "한글 기본 모음 수", - "measured": 10, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "ㅏ~ㅣ 10개", - "source": "훈민정음 1443", - "source_url": "https://www.iksi.or.kr", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "10 = n+tau", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "10 = n+tau", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "n", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-lin-v94-latin-alphabet", - "level": "L6_linguistics", - "claim": "라틴 알파벳 문자 수", - "measured": 26, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "ISO/IEC 646 기본 라틴", - "source": "ISO/IEC 646:1991", - "source_url": "https://www.iso.org/standard/4770.html", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "26 = n*tau+phi", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "26 = n*tau+phi", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "CONVENTION", - "thread": "n", - "origin": "convention", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-lin-v94-arabic-alphabet", - "level": "L6_linguistics", - "claim": "아랍 알파벳 기본자 수", - "measured": 28, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "아랍 28자", - "source": "Unicode Arabic Block", - "source_url": "https://www.unicode.org", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "28 = tau*(n+MU)", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "28 = tau*(n+MU)", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "CONVENTION", - "thread": "tau", - "origin": "convention", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-lin-v94-hebrew-alphabet", - "level": "L6_linguistics", - "claim": "히브리 알파벳 문자 수", - "measured": 22, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "알레프~타브 22자", - "source": "Unicode Hebrew Block", - "source_url": "https://www.unicode.org", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "22 = n*tau-phi", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "22 = n*tau-phi", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "CONVENTION", - "thread": "n", - "origin": "convention", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-lin-v94-greek-alphabet", - "level": "L6_linguistics", - "claim": "그리스어 알파벳 수", - "measured": 24, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "알파~오메가 24자", - "source": "ISO 843:1997", - "source_url": "https://www.iso.org", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "24 = J2", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "24 = J2", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "CONVENTION", - "thread": "J2", - "origin": "convention", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-lin-v94-xbar-levels", - "level": "L6_linguistics", - "claim": "X-바 이론 구구조 층 수", - "measured": 3, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "지정어/핵어/보충어", - "source": "Chomsky 1970 Remarks on Nominalization", - "source_url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/0024-3841(70)90009-1", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "3 = n/phi", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "3 = n/phi", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "phi", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-lin-v94-case-split-types", - "level": "L6_linguistics", - "claim": "격 표시 체계 주요 갈래", - "measured": 2, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "격지정(ergative-absolutive) / 주격-목적격", - "source": "Dixon 1994 Ergativity", - "source_url": "https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511606199", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "2 = phi", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "2 = phi", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "phi", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-lin-v94-aspect-types", - "level": "L6_linguistics", - "claim": "동사 상 기본 유형", - "measured": 2, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "완료상 / 불완료상", - "source": "Comrie 1976 Aspect", - "source_url": "https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9781139167420", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "2 = phi", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "2 = phi", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "phi", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-lin-v94-tense-basic", - "level": "L6_linguistics", - "claim": "기본 시제 수", - "measured": 3, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "과거/현재/미래", - "source": "Reichenbach 1947 Elements of Symbolic Logic", - "source_url": "https://www.uclpress.co.uk", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "3 = n/phi", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "3 = n/phi", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "phi", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-lin-v94-person-basic", - "level": "L6_linguistics", - "claim": "기본 인칭 수", - "measured": 3, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "1/2/3인칭", - "source": "Universal Grammar consensus", - "source_url": "https://www.linguisticsociety.org", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "3 = n/phi", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "3 = n/phi", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "phi", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-lin-v94-number-basic", - "level": "L6_linguistics", - "claim": "기본 수 범주", - "measured": 2, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "단수/복수", - "source": "Universal Grammar consensus", - "source_url": "https://www.linguisticsociety.org", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "2 = phi", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "2 = phi", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "phi", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-lin-v94-gender-max", - "level": "L6_linguistics", - "claim": "명사 성 최대 유형 수", - "measured": 3, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "남성/여성/중성", - "source": "Corbett 1991 Gender", - "source_url": "https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9781139166119", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "3 = n/phi", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "3 = n/phi", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "phi", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-lin-v94-syllable-elements", - "level": "L6_linguistics", - "claim": "기본 음절 필수 구성요소 최소", - "measured": 2, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "두음(Onset)+핵음(Nucleus) 또는 핵음 단독", - "source": "Blevins 1995 Handbook of Phonological Theory", - "source_url": "https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511609817", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "2 = phi", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "2 = phi", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "phi", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-lin-v94-word-classes-universal", - "level": "L6_linguistics", - "claim": "보편 문법 핵심 품사 수", - "measured": 4, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "명사/동사/형용사/부사", - "source": "Croft 2001 Radical Construction Grammar", - "source_url": "https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511804541", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "4 = tau", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "4 = tau", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "tau", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-lin-v94-jakobson-distinctive-oppositions", - "level": "L6_linguistics", - "claim": "야콥슨 변별 자질 이항 쌍 수", - "measured": 12, - "unit": "쌍", - "detail": "음소 체계 12이항 대립", - "source": "Jakobson Fant Halle 1952 Preliminaries", - "source_url": "https://www.jstor.org/stable/411025", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "12 = sigma", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "12 = sigma", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "sigma", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-lin-v94-tonal-pct", - "level": "L6_linguistics", - "claim": "전 세계 성조 언어 비율", - "measured": 60, - "unit": "%", - "detail": "Maddieson 2013 WALS Chapter 13", - "source": "WALS Online 2013 Chapter 13", - "source_url": "https://wals.info/chapter/13", - "uncertainty": 5, - "n6_expr": "60 = n*(n+tau)", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "60 = n*(n+tau)", - "grade": "EMPIRICAL", - "causal": "EMPIRICAL", - "thread": "n", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-lin-v94-morpheme-isolating", - "level": "L6_linguistics", - "claim": "고립어 형태소/단어 비율", - "measured": 1, - "unit": "개/단어", - "detail": "중국어 등 순수 고립어 이상형", - "source": "Sapir 1921 Language", - "source_url": "https://www.hup.harvard.edu", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "1 = MU", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "1 = MU", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "MU", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-lin-v94-polyrhythm-3-2", - "level": "L6_linguistics", - "claim": "언어 리듬 유형 수(강세 vs 음절)", - "measured": 2, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "강세 박자언어 / 음절 박자언어", - "source": "Pike 1945 Intonation of American English", - "source_url": "https://www.lsa.umich.edu", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "2 = phi", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "2 = phi", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "phi", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-lin-v94-iconicity-types", - "level": "L6_linguistics", - "claim": "도상성 유형 수", - "measured": 2, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "도상적(iconic) / 자의적(arbitrary)", - "source": "Haiman 1985 Natural Syntax", - "source_url": "https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511558337", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "2 = phi", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "2 = phi", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "phi", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-lin-v94-speech-act-types", - "level": "L6_linguistics", - "claim": "발화 행위 주요 유형 수", - "measured": 5, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "단언/지시/수행/표현/선언", - "source": "Searle 1969 Speech Acts", - "source_url": "https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9781139173438", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "5 = sopfr", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "5 = sopfr", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "sopfr", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-lin-v94-relevance-theory-effects", - "level": "L6_linguistics", - "claim": "관련성 이론 인지 효과 유형", - "measured": 3, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "새 정보/맥락 강화/맥락 제거", - "source": "Sperber & Wilson 1986 Relevance", - "source_url": "https://www.hup.harvard.edu", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "3 = n/phi", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "3 = n/phi", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "phi", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-lin-v94-color-term-stage1", - "level": "L6_linguistics", - "claim": "색채어 최소 단계 필수 수", - "measured": 2, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "밝음/어두움(Berlin & Kay Stage I)", - "source": "Berlin & Kay 1969 Basic Color Terms", - "source_url": "https://www.ucpress.edu", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "2 = phi", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "2 = phi", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "EMPIRICAL", - "thread": "phi", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-lin-v94-pragmatic-maxims", - "level": "L6_linguistics", - "claim": "그라이스 협력 원칙 격률 수", - "measured": 4, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "양/질/관련성/방식", - "source": "Grice 1975 Logic and Conversation", - "source_url": "https://www.jstor.org/stable/3033544", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "4 = tau", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "4 = tau", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "tau", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-mus-v94-overtone-first-ratio", - "level": "L6_music", - "claim": "배음열 첫 배음 주파수 비율", - "measured": 2, - "unit": "배", - "detail": "2f = 옥타브", - "source": "Helmholtz 1877 Sensations of Tone", - "source_url": "https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-322-85665-9", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "2 = phi", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "2 = phi", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "phi", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [ - "BT-208" - ] - }, - { - "id": "L6-mus-v94-tritone-cents", - "level": "L6_music", - "claim": "증4도(3전음) 센트값", - "measured": 600, - "unit": "¢", - "detail": "TET12 정확히 600¢", - "source": "TET12 정의 — 옥타브 중점", - "source_url": "https://www.oup.com", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "600 = n*n*J2/tau", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "600 = n*n*J2/tau", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "n", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-mus-v94-major-scale-steps", - "level": "L6_music", - "claim": "장음계 반음 단위 음정 수", - "measured": 7, - "unit": "개 음", - "detail": "온음-온음-반음-온음-온음-온음-반음", - "source": "Riemann 1882 Musik-Lexikon", - "source_url": "https://www.oup.com", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "7 = n+MU", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "7 = n+MU", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "n", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-mus-v94-triad-types", - "level": "L6_music", - "claim": "3화음 유형 수", - "measured": 4, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "장/단/증/감 3화음", - "source": "Aldwell & Schachter 2011 Harmony 4e", - "source_url": "https://www.cengage.com", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "4 = tau", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "4 = tau", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "tau", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-mus-v94-seventh-chord-types", - "level": "L6_music", - "claim": "7화음 유형 수", - "measured": 5, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "장7/속7/단7/반감7/감7", - "source": "Aldwell & Schachter 2011", - "source_url": "https://www.cengage.com", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "5 = sopfr", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "5 = sopfr", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "sopfr", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-mus-v94-diatonic-intervals", - "level": "L6_music", - "claim": "2음 음정 수(단도~7도)", - "measured": 7, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "1~7도 (옥타브 미포함)", - "source": "Music Theory Consensus", - "source_url": "https://www.oup.com", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "7 = n+MU", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "7 = n+MU", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "n", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-mus-v94-whole-tone-scale-notes", - "level": "L6_music", - "claim": "온음 음계 음 수", - "measured": 6, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "C-D-E-F#-G#-A#", - "source": "Debussy 이론 / Messiaen 1944", - "source_url": "https://www.oup.com", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "6 = n", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "6 = n", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "n", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [ - "BT-208" - ] - }, - { - "id": "L6-mus-v94-diminished-scale-notes", - "level": "L6_music", - "claim": "감음 음계(옥타토닉) 음 수", - "measured": 8, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "반음-온음 교대", - "source": "Messiaen 1944 Technique", - "source_url": "https://www.oup.com", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "8 = sigma-tau", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "8 = sigma-tau", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "sigma", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-mus-v94-augmented-scale-notes", - "level": "L6_music", - "claim": "증음 음계 음 수", - "measured": 6, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "반음+증2도 교대", - "source": "Messiaen 1944", - "source_url": "https://www.oup.com", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "6 = n", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "6 = n", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "n", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [ - "BT-208" - ] - }, - { - "id": "L6-mus-v94-tetrachord-notes", - "level": "L6_music", - "claim": "테트라코드 음 수", - "measured": 4, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "고대 그리스 4음 단위", - "source": "Aristoxenus ~350 BCE Elements of Harmony", - "source_url": "https://www.oup.com", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "4 = tau", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "4 = tau", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "tau", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-mus-v94-sonata-themes", - "level": "L6_music", - "claim": "소나타 제시부 주제 수", - "measured": 2, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "제1주제/제2주제", - "source": "Koch 1793 Versuch einer Anleitung", - "source_url": "https://www.oup.com", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "2 = phi", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "2 = phi", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "phi", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-mus-v94-fugue-sections", - "level": "L6_music", - "claim": "푸가 기본 구조 구간 수", - "measured": 3, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "제시부/전개부/재현부", - "source": "Fux 1725 Gradus ad Parnassum", - "source_url": "https://www.oup.com", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "3 = n/phi", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "3 = n/phi", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "phi", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-mus-v94-four-part-harmony", - "level": "L6_music", - "claim": "4성부 화성 성부 수", - "measured": 4, - "unit": "성부", - "detail": "소프라노/알토/테너/베이스", - "source": "Bach Chorale Tradition", - "source_url": "https://www.oup.com", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "4 = tau", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "4 = tau", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "tau", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-mus-v94-gamelan-slendro", - "level": "L6_music", - "claim": "가믈란 슬렌드로 음계 음 수", - "measured": 5, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "자바 전통 5음", - "source": "Kunst 1949 Music in Java", - "source_url": "https://doi.org/10.1007/978-94-017-3727-9", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "5 = sopfr", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "5 = sopfr", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "EMPIRICAL", - "thread": "sopfr", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-mus-v94-gamelan-pelog", - "level": "L6_music", - "claim": "가믈란 펠로그 음계 음 수", - "measured": 7, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "자바 전통 7음", - "source": "Kunst 1949 Music in Java", - "source_url": "https://doi.org/10.1007/978-94-017-3727-9", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "7 = n+MU", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "7 = n+MU", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "EMPIRICAL", - "thread": "n", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-mus-v94-sitar-main-strings", - "level": "L6_music", - "claim": "시타르 주선율 현 수", - "measured": 6, - "unit": "현", - "detail": "라가 연주용 6현", - "source": "Ravi Shankar 1999 My Music My Life", - "source_url": "https://www.simonandschuster.com", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "6 = n", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "6 = n", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "EMPIRICAL", - "thread": "n", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-mus-v94-shepherd-tone-octaves", - "level": "L6_music", - "claim": "셰퍼드 톤 구성 옥타브 수", - "measured": 6, - "unit": "옥타브", - "detail": "무한 상승 착각 음향", - "source": "Shepard 1964 JASA 36", - "source_url": "https://doi.org/10.1121/1.1907362", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "6 = n", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "6 = n", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "EMPIRICAL", - "thread": "n", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-mus-v94-fifth-ratio-numerator", - "level": "L6_music", - "claim": "순정 5도 진동수 비 분자", - "measured": 3, - "unit": "무차원", - "detail": "3:2 비율의 분자", - "source": "Pythagoras ~500 BCE", - "source_url": "https://www.jstor.org", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "3 = n/phi", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "3 = n/phi", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "phi", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [ - "BT-208" - ] - }, - { - "id": "L6-mus-v94-tet12-root-exponent", - "level": "L6_music", - "claim": "TET12 반음 비율 루트 지수", - "measured": 12, - "unit": "무차원", - "detail": "2^(1/12) 기준 지수", - "source": "Bach WTC 이론 1722", - "source_url": "https://www.baerenreiter.com", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "12 = sigma", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "12 = sigma", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "sigma", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [ - "BT-208" - ] - }, - { - "id": "L6-mus-v94-dominant-seventh-notes", - "level": "L6_music", - "claim": "속7화음 구성음 수", - "measured": 4, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "근음+장3도+완전5도+단7도", - "source": "Rameau 1722 Traité de l'Harmonie", - "source_url": "https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511570568", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "4 = tau", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "4 = tau", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "tau", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-mus-v94-polyrhythm-3-2", - "level": "L6_music", - "claim": "폴리리듬 3:2 기본 비율", - "measured": 3, - "unit": "대 2", - "detail": "가장 기본 교차리듬", - "source": "Pressing 1983 Afro-Cuban", - "source_url": "https://doi.org/10.2307/851208", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "3/phi", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "3/phi", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "phi", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-mus-v94-orchestral-range-octaves", - "level": "L6_music", - "claim": "표준 오케스트라 음역 옥타브 수", - "measured": 8, - "unit": "옥타브", - "detail": "C2~C10 약 8옥타브", - "source": "Adler 2002 Study of Orchestration 3e", - "source_url": "https://www.wwnorton.com", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "8 = sigma-tau", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "8 = sigma-tau", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "EMPIRICAL", - "thread": "sigma", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-mus-v94-arabic-maqam-basic", - "level": "L6_music", - "claim": "아랍 기본 마캄 수", - "measured": 12, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "기본 12마캄 체계", - "source": "Racy 2003 Making Music in the Arab World", - "source_url": "https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511613388", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "12 = sigma", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "12 = sigma", - "grade": "EMPIRICAL", - "causal": "EMPIRICAL", - "thread": "sigma", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-mus-v94-rhythm-subdivision", - "level": "L6_music", - "claim": "리듬 세분 유형 수", - "measured": 2, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "2분할(straight) / 3분할(swing/triplet)", - "source": "Grove Music Online 2001", - "source_url": "https://www.grovemusic.com", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "2 = phi", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "2 = phi", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "phi", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-mus-v94-rondo-min-returns", - "level": "L6_music", - "claim": "론도 주제 최소 복귀 횟수", - "measured": 3, - "unit": "회", - "detail": "ABACA 최소 구조", - "source": "Rosen 1988 Sonata Forms", - "source_url": "https://www.wwnorton.com", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "3 = n/phi", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "3 = n/phi", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "phi", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-mus-v94-pentatonic-types", - "level": "L6_music", - "claim": "펜타토닉 음계 주요 유형", - "measured": 2, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "장조(메이저) / 단조(마이너)", - "source": "Music Theory texts", - "source_url": "https://www.oup.com", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "2 = phi", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "2 = phi", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "phi", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-mus-v94-string-open-harmonics-nodes", - "level": "L6_music", - "claim": "개방현 기본음 노드 수", - "measured": 0, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "정상파 기본음: 노드=0", - "source": "물리학 진동 이론", - "source_url": "https://www.nist.gov", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "0 = n-n", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "0 = n-n", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "n", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-mus-v94-melodic-contour-basic", - "level": "L6_music", - "claim": "선율 윤곽 기본 방향 수", - "measured": 3, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "상행/하행/수평", - "source": "Narmour 1990 The Analysis and Cognition of Basic Melodic Structures", - "source_url": "https://www.uchicago.edu", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "3 = n/phi", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "3 = n/phi", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "phi", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - }, - { - "id": "L6-mus-v94-harmonic-series-partial-6", - "level": "L6_music", - "claim": "6번째 배음 비율 정수", - "measured": 6, - "unit": "무차원", - "detail": "6f (제6배음)", - "source": "물리 음향학", - "source_url": "https://www.asa.org", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "6 = n", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "6 = n", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "n", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [ - "BT-208" - ] - }, - { - "id": "L6-mus-v94-tonal-function-basic", - "level": "L6_music", - "claim": "조성 화성 기본 기능 수", - "measured": 3, - "unit": "개", - "detail": "으뜸화음(T)/버금딸림(S)/딸림(D)", - "source": "Riemann 1893 Vereinfachte Harmonielehre", - "source_url": "https://www.oup.com", - "uncertainty": 0, - "n6_expr": "3 = n/phi", - "n6_value": 6, - "verify": "3 = n/phi", - "grade": "EXACT", - "causal": "STRUCTURAL", - "thread": "phi", - "origin": "natural", - "bt_refs": [] - } -] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/shared/discovery/auto_discovery_20cycles.json b/shared/discovery/auto_discovery_20cycles.json deleted file mode 100644 index d36db6b8..00000000 --- a/shared/discovery/auto_discovery_20cycles.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,1786 +0,0 @@ -{ - "config": { - "n_cycles": 20, - "max_cells": 32, - "steps": 50, - "repeats": 1, - "auto_register": false, - "total_interventions_available": 17 - }, - "phi_trajectory": [ - 0.9879485871293632, - 1.0115007773550473, - 1.0145113798508474, - 0.9745660329737973, - 0.986931269826818, - 0.97336038961033, - 0.9821133329557432, - 0.9739655228705799, - 0.9792888273145581, - 0.9703317529824169, - 0.9744545904564421, - 0.9777870812347565, - 0.9665931059210493, - 0.9737052200750602, - 0.9640352023909593, - 0.9755865691317064, - 0.9837580915122163, - 0.9737200701417988, - 0.9823561257664286, - 0.9545256870612339 - ], - "intervention_usage": { - "tension_eq": 1, - "symmetrize": 1, - "DD71_diversity": 1, - "DD72_temporal_comp": 1, - "pink_noise": 1, - "DD72_hebbian_boost": 1, - "DD73_entropy_bound": 1, - "DD73_channel_limit": 1, - "DD73_incompressible": 1, - "DD74_natural_reg": 1, - "DD75_soc_free_will": 1, - "DD75_decisive": 1, - "DD75_veto": 1, - "none": 7 - }, - "unique_interventions_used": 14, - "total_law_changes": 239, - "cycle_summaries": [ - { - "cycle": 0, - "phi": 0.9879485871293632, - "dphi_pct": -6.043367530375841, - "intervention": "tension_eq", - "n_changed": 14, - "top3": [ - "r_div_phi", - "consensus", - "stabilization" - ], - "elapsed": 2.569697141647339 - }, - { - "cycle": 1, - "phi": 1.0115007773550473, - "dphi_pct": -1.7980082598387883, - "intervention": "symmetrize", - "n_changed": 13, - "top3": [ - "r_div_phi", - "consensus", - "coupling_symmetry" - ], - "elapsed": 2.4428679943084717 - }, - { - "cycle": 2, - "phi": 1.0145113798508474, - "dphi_pct": 0.880576247658337, - "intervention": "DD71_diversity", - "n_changed": 11, - "top3": [ - "consensus", - "ac1", - "phi_volatility" - ], - "elapsed": 2.330770969390869 - }, - { - "cycle": 3, - "phi": 0.9745660329737973, - "dphi_pct": -3.976808115194954, - "intervention": "DD72_temporal_comp", - "n_changed": 12, - "top3": [ - "r_div_phi", - "r_tension_phi", - "ac1" - ], - "elapsed": 1.815953016281128 - }, - { - "cycle": 4, - "phi": 0.986931269826818, - "dphi_pct": 1.6709732762381808, - "intervention": "pink_noise", - "n_changed": 12, - "top3": [ - "r_tstd_phi", - "r_tension_phi", - "r_div_phi" - ], - "elapsed": 2.0517070293426514 - }, - { - "cycle": 5, - "phi": 0.97336038961033, - "dphi_pct": 0.8504536739004176, - "intervention": "DD72_hebbian_boost", - "n_changed": 9, - "top3": [ - "r_tension_phi", - "ac1", - "consensus" - ], - "elapsed": 2.0661869049072266 - }, - { - "cycle": 6, - "phi": 0.9821133329557432, - "dphi_pct": -0.40082654116941446, - "intervention": "DD73_entropy_bound", - "n_changed": 15, - "top3": [ - "ac1", - "faction_count", - "r_tstd_phi" - ], - "elapsed": 2.069796085357666 - }, - { - "cycle": 7, - "phi": 0.9739655228705799, - "dphi_pct": 1.9966505844083937, - "intervention": "DD73_channel_limit", - "n_changed": 15, - "top3": [ - "ac1", - "faction_count", - "r_tstd_phi" - ], - "elapsed": 2.1636321544647217 - }, - { - "cycle": 8, - "phi": 0.9792888273145581, - "dphi_pct": 0.29300447341548813, - "intervention": "DD73_incompressible", - "n_changed": 14, - "top3": [ - "ac1", - "r_tension_phi", - "consensus" - ], - "elapsed": 1.9262731075286865 - }, - { - "cycle": 9, - "phi": 0.9703317529824169, - "dphi_pct": 0.06839827511333907, - "intervention": "DD74_natural_reg", - "n_changed": 13, - "top3": [ - "ac1", - "r_tension_phi", - "r_tstd_phi" - ], - "elapsed": 2.489201307296753 - }, - { - "cycle": 10, - "phi": 0.9744545904564421, - "dphi_pct": -0.2153113555068278, - "intervention": "DD75_soc_free_will", - "n_changed": 13, - "top3": [ - "ac1", - "r_tstd_phi", - "output_divergence" - ], - "elapsed": 5.1953489780426025 - }, - { - "cycle": 11, - "phi": 0.9777870812347565, - "dphi_pct": 0.5719306294950001, - "intervention": "DD75_decisive", - "n_changed": 11, - "top3": [ - "r_tension_phi", - "r_tstd_phi", - "r_div_phi" - ], - "elapsed": 4.709558010101318 - }, - { - "cycle": 12, - "phi": 0.9665931059210493, - "dphi_pct": -0.7878481608060101, - "intervention": "DD75_veto", - "n_changed": 15, - "top3": [ - "cells", - "faction_count", - "hidden_diversity" - ], - "elapsed": 4.5617451667785645 - }, - { - "cycle": 13, - "phi": 0.9737052200750602, - "dphi_pct": -1.7885449497554244, - "intervention": "none", - "n_changed": 13, - "top3": [ - "ac1", - "r_tstd_phi", - "consensus" - ], - "elapsed": 4.5264809131622314 - }, - { - "cycle": 14, - "phi": 0.9640352023909593, - "dphi_pct": 0.9025732187800203, - "intervention": "none", - "n_changed": 7, - "top3": [ - "ac1", - "r_tstd_phi", - "r_div_phi" - ], - "elapsed": 4.200294017791748 - }, - { - "cycle": 15, - "phi": 0.9755865691317064, - "dphi_pct": 1.000526650231749, - "intervention": "none", - "n_changed": 13, - "top3": [ - "r_tstd_phi", - "r_tension_phi", - "ac1" - ], - "elapsed": 3.7006328105926514 - }, - { - "cycle": 16, - "phi": 0.9837580915122163, - "dphi_pct": 1.1197161409490028, - "intervention": "none", - "n_changed": 11, - "top3": [ - "ac1", - "r_tstd_phi", - "r_tension_phi" - ], - "elapsed": 3.010503053665161 - }, - { - "cycle": 17, - "phi": 0.9737200701417988, - "dphi_pct": -0.4484625443774073, - "intervention": "none", - "n_changed": 9, - "top3": [ - "r_tstd_phi", - "ac1", - "output_divergence" - ], - "elapsed": 3.168240785598755 - }, - { - "cycle": 18, - "phi": 0.9823561257664286, - "dphi_pct": 0.8536847375821534, - "intervention": "none", - "n_changed": 12, - "top3": [ - "ac1", - "r_tension_phi", - "r_tstd_phi" - ], - "elapsed": 2.719943046569824 - }, - { - "cycle": 19, - "phi": 0.9545256870612339, - "dphi_pct": -2.418373972086537, - "intervention": "none", - "n_changed": 7, - "top3": [ - "r_tension_phi", - "r_tstd_phi", - "consensus" - ], - "elapsed": 2.972416877746582 - } - ], - "law_candidates": [], - "law_change_tracker": { - "phi": [ - { - "cycle": 0, - "before": 1.0514942491673096, - "after": 0.9879485871293632, - "change_pct": -6.043367530375841 - } - ], - "r_tension_phi": [ - { - "cycle": 0, - "before": 0.23589502463281004, - "after": 0.16096021148129372, - "change_pct": -31.766169408684437 - }, - { - "cycle": 1, - "before": 0.2160702997606825, - "after": 0.06795856376777952, - "change_pct": -68.54793840567177 - }, - { - "cycle": 2, - "before": 0.1337197597891129, - "after": 0.11834903459782448, - "change_pct": -11.494729885492864 - }, - { - "cycle": 3, - "before": 0.10094509501216485, - "after": -0.21801371618917176, - "change_pct": -315.972570200562 - }, - { - "cycle": 4, - "before": -0.030141106494774354, - "after": 0.06841520086343478, - "change_pct": 326.9830434901125 - }, - { - "cycle": 5, - "before": 0.0024047532352796963, - "after": -0.12144179391482564, - "change_pct": -5150.073002633918 - }, - { - "cycle": 6, - "before": -0.06453081068530271, - "after": -0.1356481393902641, - "change_pct": -110.20678021818003 - }, - { - "cycle": 7, - "before": -0.33491444350654936, - "after": -0.3021484910821492, - "change_pct": 9.783379922747173 - }, - { - "cycle": 8, - "before": -0.025741314917938796, - "after": -0.12725083230882847, - "change_pct": -394.34472448083443 - }, - { - "cycle": 9, - "before": -0.2391794095713112, - "after": 0.021973718503589486, - "change_pct": 109.18712799859055 - }, - { - "cycle": 10, - "before": -0.38805840686289145, - "after": -0.44848550419756983, - "change_pct": -15.57165010885293 - }, - { - "cycle": 11, - "before": 0.09969684279898021, - "after": -0.2130246516603986, - "change_pct": -313.67241497298204 - }, - { - "cycle": 12, - "before": -0.2425240589904086, - "after": -0.3441491514267249, - "change_pct": -41.903097308929425 - }, - { - "cycle": 13, - "before": 0.07642816038091302, - "after": 0.10645251384890443, - "change_pct": 39.284412078417134 - }, - { - "cycle": 14, - "before": -0.2625909558760903, - "after": -0.3026793493337803, - "change_pct": -15.266479122992585 - }, - { - "cycle": 15, - "before": -0.025973117708005405, - "after": 0.01611331110496631, - "change_pct": 162.03841712849083 - }, - { - "cycle": 16, - "before": -0.4082325069484748, - "after": -0.03822863535979262, - "change_pct": 90.63557293720913 - }, - { - "cycle": 18, - "before": -0.16996568994809627, - "after": -0.04128560122687219, - "change_pct": 75.70944980749945 - }, - { - "cycle": 19, - "before": -0.0011775355484379194, - "after": -0.5769835473573682, - "change_pct": -48899.246614913325 - } - ], - "r_tstd_phi": [ - { - "cycle": 0, - "before": 0.3690787538969631, - "after": 0.41466268292615316, - "change_pct": 12.350732343134515 - }, - { - "cycle": 1, - "before": 0.3216694910949465, - "after": 0.24020046695593475, - "change_pct": -25.32693537758131 - }, - { - "cycle": 2, - "before": 0.3324687114898538, - "after": 0.2520845935045636, - "change_pct": -24.17794974602997 - }, - { - "cycle": 3, - "before": 0.28187756631829, - "after": -0.09979467387114244, - "change_pct": -135.4035531009433 - }, - { - "cycle": 4, - "before": -0.00947837591396193, - "after": 0.06442127501139543, - "change_pct": 779.6657528269266 - }, - { - "cycle": 5, - "before": 0.1056149281556335, - "after": 0.04300347625378324, - "change_pct": -59.28276711942313 - }, - { - "cycle": 6, - "before": 0.034167521363204376, - "after": -0.007847178604374274, - "change_pct": -122.96677748718714 - }, - { - "cycle": 7, - "before": -0.27889755782984593, - "after": -0.12539305060247405, - "change_pct": 55.03974592743629 - }, - { - "cycle": 8, - "before": -0.08593972039978738, - "after": -0.005933944176486859, - "change_pct": 93.09522517773802 - }, - { - "cycle": 9, - "before": -0.1206453602177804, - "after": -0.004372050830195875, - "change_pct": 96.37611357593549 - }, - { - "cycle": 10, - "before": -0.2121185954885165, - "after": -0.3208359785167595, - "change_pct": -51.2531128060051 - }, - { - "cycle": 11, - "before": 0.17773153588817195, - "after": -0.1704404790734468, - "change_pct": -195.8977134933934 - }, - { - "cycle": 12, - "before": -0.16089837038030824, - "after": -0.1965968607997709, - "change_pct": -22.186980722728105 - }, - { - "cycle": 13, - "before": 0.06401232834839637, - "after": 0.1163489140418898, - "change_pct": 81.76016564909804 - }, - { - "cycle": 14, - "before": -0.2106121912491277, - "after": -0.2718367725381915, - "change_pct": -29.069818288269378 - }, - { - "cycle": 15, - "before": 0.0018975309561774973, - "after": 0.08647559454995556, - "change_pct": 4457.269238134449 - }, - { - "cycle": 16, - "before": -0.3616110830176442, - "after": -0.012148637348563597, - "change_pct": 96.64041343888489 - }, - { - "cycle": 17, - "before": -0.03551213776624368, - "after": 0.06120389956147734, - "change_pct": 272.34642409969234 - }, - { - "cycle": 18, - "before": -0.1052551554054962, - "after": -0.060035947632413676, - "change_pct": 42.961513475397204 - }, - { - "cycle": 19, - "before": -0.041078635566154584, - "after": -0.50913728573386, - "change_pct": -1139.4211217505656 - } - ], - "r_div_phi": [ - { - "cycle": 0, - "before": 0.18312805276357227, - "after": -0.2904642646302114, - "change_pct": -258.6126539581654 - }, - { - "cycle": 1, - "before": 0.026033533166580126, - "after": -0.17537120969818573, - "change_pct": -773.6358394999338 - }, - { - "cycle": 2, - "before": -0.036666207619775355, - "after": -0.02895562549381585, - "change_pct": 21.029123616812008 - }, - { - "cycle": 3, - "before": -0.04777295253997966, - "after": -0.3238811951910271, - "change_pct": -577.959343040356 - }, - { - "cycle": 4, - "before": -0.24884265908165681, - "after": -0.039522631565851146, - "change_pct": 84.11742114004579 - }, - { - "cycle": 5, - "before": -0.1907712848425713, - "after": -0.22912284621749998, - "change_pct": -20.103424583305205 - }, - { - "cycle": 6, - "before": -0.2795005094649475, - "after": -0.44211188791206485, - "change_pct": -58.1792780121965 - }, - { - "cycle": 7, - "before": -0.4252382474145037, - "after": -0.20606762011954058, - "change_pct": 51.540666585742265 - }, - { - "cycle": 8, - "before": -0.4293326013838444, - "after": -0.28600226320726274, - "change_pct": 33.384452453550644 - }, - { - "cycle": 9, - "before": -0.3574657732040109, - "after": -0.38192602019252714, - "change_pct": -6.842682243190991 - }, - { - "cycle": 10, - "before": -0.32719134075267253, - "after": -0.28769114198704165, - "change_pct": 12.072507381999912 - }, - { - "cycle": 11, - "before": -0.20653432956426968, - "after": -0.336073528791252, - "change_pct": -62.72042013561341 - }, - { - "cycle": 12, - "before": -0.3183104670198198, - "after": -0.279622765540049, - "change_pct": 12.154077697156557 - }, - { - "cycle": 13, - "before": -0.2731225715797662, - "after": -0.2934319390728656, - "change_pct": -7.435990140114784 - }, - { - "cycle": 14, - "before": -0.388021889775999, - "after": -0.49207951513215265, - "change_pct": -26.817462647848306 - }, - { - "cycle": 15, - "before": -0.4365938597677788, - "after": -0.2901686236049689, - "change_pct": 33.5380887492766 - }, - { - "cycle": 17, - "before": -0.3675383885068454, - "after": -0.41411893857377874, - "change_pct": -12.67365573870273 - }, - { - "cycle": 18, - "before": -0.42975239706957236, - "after": -0.27449383578774283, - "change_pct": 36.127445091759384 - }, - { - "cycle": 19, - "before": -0.28421660533910836, - "after": -0.4079424055223398, - "change_pct": -43.532220798855164 - } - ], - "ac1": [ - { - "cycle": 0, - "before": -0.14565843950800672, - "after": -0.06971756515740171, - "change_pct": 52.13626797534832 - }, - { - "cycle": 1, - "before": -0.17229443759566562, - "after": -0.1986807422227649, - "change_pct": -15.314658438957684 - }, - { - "cycle": 2, - "before": -0.1967838874678225, - "after": -0.006851992836949645, - "change_pct": 96.51801124313592 - }, - { - "cycle": 3, - "before": -0.2554561557449393, - "after": 0.36196016027354017, - "change_pct": 241.69169625919685 - }, - { - "cycle": 4, - "before": 0.07070388736295526, - "after": 0.03265759624195246, - "change_pct": -53.810748658972386 - }, - { - "cycle": 5, - "before": 0.08243325229118513, - "after": -0.07792192599008704, - "change_pct": -194.52729793413656 - }, - { - "cycle": 6, - "before": -0.21697323818797673, - "after": 0.3979092936274428, - "change_pct": 283.3909550092581 - }, - { - "cycle": 7, - "before": 0.010193659512323256, - "after": -0.06698094431419974, - "change_pct": -757.0843791008082 - }, - { - "cycle": 8, - "before": -0.022210082261144223, - "after": 0.2530220946067232, - "change_pct": 1239.221780593657 - }, - { - "cycle": 9, - "before": -0.014773159680924162, - "after": -0.06704957686213517, - "change_pct": -353.860773932559 - }, - { - "cycle": 10, - "before": 0.05710933050914893, - "after": 0.2528393460499017, - "change_pct": 342.72861158720247 - }, - { - "cycle": 11, - "before": 0.30101323849967765, - "after": 0.32932284431616804, - "change_pct": 9.404771018574557 - }, - { - "cycle": 12, - "before": 0.26376993953661715, - "after": 0.13914602613335328, - "change_pct": -47.24720095936606 - }, - { - "cycle": 13, - "before": -0.012309136380393696, - "after": 0.11384452665148861, - "change_pct": 1024.8782622379833 - }, - { - "cycle": 14, - "before": 0.3747839286586265, - "after": 0.07185967382977804, - "change_pct": -80.82637265504741 - }, - { - "cycle": 15, - "before": -0.3470013172241351, - "after": 0.20460714195006224, - "change_pct": 158.96437039110788 - }, - { - "cycle": 16, - "before": -0.032031809780568486, - "after": -0.2959537177957199, - "change_pct": -823.9369233993605 - }, - { - "cycle": 17, - "before": 0.16320888213001794, - "after": -0.17546089665316653, - "change_pct": -207.5069532756117 - }, - { - "cycle": 18, - "before": -0.22920343141870908, - "after": 0.1715761397538556, - "change_pct": 174.8575790038763 - }, - { - "cycle": 19, - "before": -0.12253013012906014, - "after": 0.00282646860561916, - "change_pct": 102.30675394096298 - } - ], - "stabilization": [ - { - "cycle": 0, - "before": 9.805919329315602, - "after": 18.376743502454683, - "change_pct": 87.4045959925032 - }, - { - "cycle": 1, - "before": 9.080826188172766, - "after": 6.6748586273044035, - "change_pct": -26.495029317948976 - }, - { - "cycle": 2, - "before": 8.748498271666893, - "after": 6.29421110816531, - "change_pct": -28.053810920327884 - }, - { - "cycle": 3, - "before": 9.506635934737991, - "after": 5.372364361927207, - "change_pct": -43.48827073206657 - }, - { - "cycle": 5, - "before": 10.611713384760213, - "after": 8.518940667078942, - "change_pct": -19.721346042824358 - }, - { - "cycle": 6, - "before": 7.90032440228362, - "after": 7.338490228293432, - "change_pct": -7.111532962213392 - }, - { - "cycle": 7, - "before": 8.46799759385883, - "after": 9.217910923193601, - "change_pct": 8.855851941651768 - }, - { - "cycle": 9, - "before": 7.826747368156783, - "after": 6.922918634914174, - "change_pct": -11.547948218181256 - }, - { - "cycle": 10, - "before": 7.612920859466317, - "after": 9.6333339179246, - "change_pct": 26.539262600451092 - }, - { - "cycle": 11, - "before": 6.33795592249888, - "after": 7.876965901206507, - "change_pct": 24.282434234740435 - }, - { - "cycle": 12, - "before": 6.844872721882082, - "after": 5.895404227659436, - "change_pct": -13.871236658460138 - }, - { - "cycle": 13, - "before": 9.082533469530285, - "after": 11.702812450733871, - "change_pct": 28.849648503845238 - }, - { - "cycle": 14, - "before": 8.145775286369286, - "after": 8.714446840338216, - "change_pct": 6.981183914077703 - }, - { - "cycle": 15, - "before": 10.681311039801864, - "after": 5.809605939308336, - "change_pct": -45.609617418124515 - }, - { - "cycle": 16, - "before": 7.971509832651532, - "after": 6.3843184372567645, - "change_pct": -19.91080019613833 - }, - { - "cycle": 17, - "before": 8.14491474067883, - "after": 8.575142027987852, - "change_pct": 5.282158266928212 - }, - { - "cycle": 18, - "before": 9.240136539758307, - "after": 7.428180778214794, - "change_pct": -19.60962106725436 - } - ], - "consensus": [ - { - "cycle": 0, - "before": 0.96, - "after": 0.0, - "change_pct": -100.0 - }, - { - "cycle": 1, - "before": 0.18, - "after": 0.4, - "change_pct": 122.22222222222223 - }, - { - "cycle": 2, - "before": 0.08, - "after": 0.3, - "change_pct": 274.99999999999994 - }, - { - "cycle": 3, - "before": 0.18, - "after": 0.4, - "change_pct": 122.22222222222223 - }, - { - "cycle": 4, - "before": 0.48, - "after": 0.54, - "change_pct": 12.50000000000001 - }, - { - "cycle": 5, - "before": 0.08, - "after": 0.18, - "change_pct": 124.99999999999997 - }, - { - "cycle": 6, - "before": 0.48, - "after": 0.6, - "change_pct": 25.0 - }, - { - "cycle": 7, - "before": 0.24, - "after": 0.18, - "change_pct": -25.0 - }, - { - "cycle": 8, - "before": 0.18, - "after": 0.54, - "change_pct": 200.00000000000006 - }, - { - "cycle": 9, - "before": 0.64, - "after": 0.58, - "change_pct": -9.375000000000009 - }, - { - "cycle": 12, - "before": 0.32, - "after": 0.18, - "change_pct": -43.75000000000001 - }, - { - "cycle": 13, - "before": 0.28, - "after": 0.08, - "change_pct": -71.42857142857143 - }, - { - "cycle": 15, - "before": 0.08, - "after": 0.18, - "change_pct": 124.99999999999997 - }, - { - "cycle": 18, - "before": 0.48, - "after": 0.56, - "change_pct": 16.666666666666682 - }, - { - "cycle": 19, - "before": 0.18, - "after": 0.4, - "change_pct": 122.22222222222223 - } - ], - "mutual_info": [ - { - "cycle": 0, - "before": 1.0499858627211842, - "after": 0.9523070472868443, - "change_pct": -9.302869581614333 - }, - { - "cycle": 4, - "before": 1.0555382144354284, - "after": 0.9765900566399667, - "change_pct": -7.47942203472836 - }, - { - "cycle": 5, - "before": 0.929317475243487, - "after": 0.9985300178922814, - "change_pct": 7.447674717475886 - }, - { - "cycle": 6, - "before": 0.9911117865507777, - "after": 1.0612413034024615, - "change_pct": 7.075843290669093 - }, - { - "cycle": 7, - "before": 0.9260610225415785, - "after": 0.9791541970726755, - "change_pct": 5.733226346724162 - }, - { - "cycle": 8, - "before": 1.0848143699330912, - "after": 1.0033141758979787, - "change_pct": -7.512823971915056 - }, - { - "cycle": 9, - "before": 1.0529784757847296, - "after": 0.965890481901483, - "change_pct": -8.270633815030692 - }, - { - "cycle": 10, - "before": 1.080324616465402, - "after": 0.9867857728182418, - "change_pct": -8.658401578703245 - }, - { - "cycle": 12, - "before": 1.0657800806480262, - "after": 0.9896663515834891, - "change_pct": -7.141598013190268 - }, - { - "cycle": 15, - "before": 0.9578546151876859, - "after": 1.0168875206928398, - "change_pct": 6.1630339896192705 - }, - { - "cycle": 16, - "before": 1.021703597444257, - "after": 0.8989601522985788, - "change_pct": -12.013606045110837 - }, - { - "cycle": 18, - "before": 0.9973081408882031, - "after": 1.0828072644914042, - "change_pct": 8.572989640599499 - } - ], - "output_divergence": [ - { - "cycle": 0, - "before": 0.668615847826004, - "after": 0.817073866724968, - "change_pct": 22.203784038573616 - }, - { - "cycle": 1, - "before": 0.8101763725280762, - "after": 0.6846858859062195, - "change_pct": -15.489279973726694 - }, - { - "cycle": 2, - "before": 0.8652066141366959, - "after": 0.7861692160367966, - "change_pct": -9.135089446670827 - }, - { - "cycle": 3, - "before": 1.1769253611564636, - "after": 0.6386028528213501, - "change_pct": -45.73973219560416 - }, - { - "cycle": 4, - "before": 0.9117141515016556, - "after": 0.7647280842065811, - "change_pct": -16.12194645141554 - }, - { - "cycle": 5, - "before": 0.7219142913818359, - "after": 0.4974019527435303, - "change_pct": -31.0995836096499 - }, - { - "cycle": 6, - "before": 0.755374863743782, - "after": 0.8003922998905182, - "change_pct": 5.959615325776283 - }, - { - "cycle": 7, - "before": 0.7353867292404175, - "after": 0.7973854839801788, - "change_pct": 8.430768774383514 - }, - { - "cycle": 8, - "before": 0.6615418791770935, - "after": 0.5959819853305817, - "change_pct": -9.910165313806472 - }, - { - "cycle": 9, - "before": 0.6457215845584869, - "after": 0.5550204515457153, - "change_pct": -14.046476868941687 - }, - { - "cycle": 10, - "before": 0.6221915185451508, - "after": 0.8114618062973022, - "change_pct": 30.41994018091339 - }, - { - "cycle": 11, - "before": 0.6943472027778625, - "after": 0.7303697764873505, - "change_pct": 5.1879770762196555 - }, - { - "cycle": 12, - "before": 0.6602142453193665, - "after": 0.7805736660957336, - "change_pct": 18.230358043568952 - }, - { - "cycle": 13, - "before": 0.6128875315189362, - "after": 0.522438257932663, - "change_pct": -14.757890956291812 - }, - { - "cycle": 15, - "before": 0.7614132016897202, - "after": 0.6008610725402832, - "change_pct": -21.086071110028215 - }, - { - "cycle": 16, - "before": 0.7045547664165497, - "after": 0.7613575756549835, - "change_pct": 8.062227657239445 - }, - { - "cycle": 17, - "before": 0.5126757621765137, - "after": 0.737754762172699, - "change_pct": 43.902797167674734 - }, - { - "cycle": 18, - "before": 0.7730250954627991, - "after": 0.638264536857605, - "change_pct": -17.432882761007242 - } - ], - "faction_entropy": [ - { - "cycle": 0, - "before": 2.9219280937332064, - "after": 3.3219280934446673, - "change_pct": 13.689590807157758 - }, - { - "cycle": 1, - "before": 3.506890593877284, - "after": 3.2389012551599357, - "change_pct": -7.641793535995498 - }, - { - "cycle": 4, - "before": 2.419381944780754, - "after": 2.6635327537943687, - "change_pct": 10.091453709502645 - }, - { - "cycle": 6, - "before": 1.37095059402186, - "after": 2.8073549210477178, - "change_pct": 104.77433200652261 - }, - { - "cycle": 7, - "before": 2.550340708536502, - "after": 3.506890593877284, - "change_pct": 37.50674888806101 - }, - { - "cycle": 8, - "before": 2.9219280937332064, - "after": 1.9219280943102843, - "change_pct": -34.22397702283188 - }, - { - "cycle": 10, - "before": 2.8553885410533777, - "after": 3.026986832060861, - "change_pct": 6.009630162071717 - }, - { - "cycle": 12, - "before": 2.3219280941660148, - "after": 3.0849624994227307, - "change_pct": 32.862103144963285 - }, - { - "cycle": 13, - "before": 2.725480555987981, - "after": 3.521640634612085, - "change_pct": 29.2117321062853 - }, - { - "cycle": 15, - "before": 3.521640634612085, - "after": 3.0849624994227307, - "change_pct": -12.399849402505982 - }, - { - "cycle": 17, - "before": 2.646439343661129, - "after": 3.095795253702508, - "change_pct": 16.97964138561108 - }, - { - "cycle": 18, - "before": 2.5949066172340536, - "after": 2.251629166666475, - "change_pct": -13.228894184002757 - } - ], - "coupling_symmetry": [ - { - "cycle": 0, - "before": 0.13896457850933075, - "after": 0.04125162586569786, - "change_pct": -70.31500666702053 - }, - { - "cycle": 1, - "before": 0.007145840208977461, - "after": 0.0, - "change_pct": -100.0 - } - ], - "coupling_density": [ - { - "cycle": 0, - "before": 0.9777777777777777, - "after": 0.8888888888888888, - "change_pct": -9.090909090909092 - }, - { - "cycle": 2, - "before": 0.9340659340659341, - "after": 0.8857142857142857, - "change_pct": -5.1764705882353 - }, - { - "cycle": 3, - "before": 0.9428571428571428, - "after": 0.8761904761904762, - "change_pct": -7.070707070707069 - }, - { - "cycle": 4, - "before": 0.8888888888888888, - "after": 0.9454545454545454, - "change_pct": 6.363636363636367 - }, - { - "cycle": 5, - "before": 0.8589743589743589, - "after": 0.9560439560439561, - "change_pct": 11.300639658848628 - }, - { - "cycle": 6, - "before": 0.9, - "after": 0.8095238095238095, - "change_pct": -10.052910052910054 - }, - { - "cycle": 8, - "before": 0.8444444444444444, - "after": 1.0, - "change_pct": 18.421052631578945 - }, - { - "cycle": 9, - "before": 0.9523809523809523, - "after": 1.0, - "change_pct": 5.000000000000006 - }, - { - "cycle": 10, - "before": 0.8636363636363636, - "after": 0.9358974358974359, - "change_pct": 8.367071524966262 - }, - { - "cycle": 11, - "before": 0.8095238095238095, - "after": 0.7619047619047619, - "change_pct": -5.882352941176476 - }, - { - "cycle": 12, - "before": 1.0, - "after": 0.8787878787878788, - "change_pct": -12.121212121212121 - }, - { - "cycle": 13, - "before": 0.8888888888888888, - "after": 0.9560439560439561, - "change_pct": 7.554945054945065 - }, - { - "cycle": 14, - "before": 0.9642857142857143, - "after": 0.8095238095238095, - "change_pct": -16.049382716049383 - }, - { - "cycle": 15, - "before": 0.9010989010989011, - "after": 0.9696969696969697, - "change_pct": 7.612712490761273 - }, - { - "cycle": 16, - "before": 0.9523809523809523, - "after": 0.8, - "change_pct": -15.999999999999993 - }, - { - "cycle": 18, - "before": 0.8545454545454545, - "after": 0.8, - "change_pct": -6.382978723404245 - } - ], - "tension_range": [ - { - "cycle": 0, - "before": 0.4541899148582091, - "after": 0.4277107936509461, - "change_pct": -5.829966791651317 - }, - { - "cycle": 1, - "before": 0.39356954723608767, - "after": 0.43399401120743747, - "change_pct": 10.271237766041049 - }, - { - "cycle": 7, - "before": 0.43411906512822257, - "after": 0.3937100156989438, - "change_pct": -9.308287213173518 - }, - { - "cycle": 9, - "before": 0.3960785432542524, - "after": 0.43348717922193103, - "change_pct": 9.444751957609862 - }, - { - "cycle": 19, - "before": 0.43359432739694814, - "after": 0.3945951006523039, - "change_pct": -8.994404280787814 - } - ], - "faction_count": [ - { - "cycle": 0, - "before": 8.0, - "after": 10.0, - "change_pct": 25.0 - }, - { - "cycle": 1, - "before": 12.0, - "after": 10.0, - "change_pct": -16.666666666666664 - }, - { - "cycle": 3, - "before": 12.0, - "after": 11.0, - "change_pct": -8.333333333333332 - }, - { - "cycle": 4, - "before": 6.0, - "after": 7.0, - "change_pct": 16.666666666666664 - }, - { - "cycle": 6, - "before": 3.0, - "after": 7.0, - "change_pct": 133.33333333333331 - }, - { - "cycle": 7, - "before": 7.0, - "after": 12.0, - "change_pct": 71.42857142857143 - }, - { - "cycle": 8, - "before": 8.0, - "after": 4.0, - "change_pct": -50.0 - }, - { - "cycle": 10, - "before": 8.0, - "after": 9.0, - "change_pct": 12.5 - }, - { - "cycle": 12, - "before": 5.0, - "after": 9.0, - "change_pct": 80.0 - }, - { - "cycle": 13, - "before": 7.0, - "after": 12.0, - "change_pct": 71.42857142857143 - }, - { - "cycle": 15, - "before": 12.0, - "after": 9.0, - "change_pct": -25.0 - }, - { - "cycle": 17, - "before": 7.0, - "after": 9.0, - "change_pct": 28.57142857142857 - }, - { - "cycle": 18, - "before": 7.0, - "after": 5.0, - "change_pct": -28.57142857142857 - }, - { - "cycle": 19, - "before": 12.0, - "after": 11.0, - "change_pct": -8.333333333333332 - } - ], - "cells": [ - { - "cycle": 1, - "before": 15.0, - "after": 16.0, - "change_pct": 6.666666666666667 - }, - { - "cycle": 2, - "before": 14.0, - "after": 15.0, - "change_pct": 7.142857142857142 - }, - { - "cycle": 3, - "before": 15.0, - "after": 16.0, - "change_pct": 6.666666666666667 - }, - { - "cycle": 6, - "before": 8.0, - "after": 12.0, - "change_pct": 50.0 - }, - { - "cycle": 7, - "before": 12.0, - "after": 15.0, - "change_pct": 25.0 - }, - { - "cycle": 8, - "before": 14.0, - "after": 6.0, - "change_pct": -57.14285714285714 - }, - { - "cycle": 9, - "before": 10.0, - "after": 7.0, - "change_pct": -30.0 - }, - { - "cycle": 10, - "before": 14.0, - "after": 13.0, - "change_pct": -7.142857142857142 - }, - { - "cycle": 11, - "before": 7.0, - "after": 8.0, - "change_pct": 14.285714285714285 - }, - { - "cycle": 12, - "before": 6.0, - "after": 14.0, - "change_pct": 133.33333333333331 - }, - { - "cycle": 13, - "before": 11.0, - "after": 14.0, - "change_pct": 27.27272727272727 - }, - { - "cycle": 15, - "before": 14.0, - "after": 15.0, - "change_pct": 7.142857142857142 - }, - { - "cycle": 16, - "before": 10.0, - "after": 7.0, - "change_pct": -30.0 - } - ], - "hidden_diversity": [ - { - "cycle": 1, - "before": 0.04365488514304161, - "after": 0.03558818995952606, - "change_pct": -18.478333311572904 - }, - { - "cycle": 2, - "before": 0.042879898101091385, - "after": 0.0383354015648365, - "change_pct": -10.59819807766571 - }, - { - "cycle": 3, - "before": 0.037999022752046585, - "after": 0.034646157175302505, - "change_pct": -8.823557380994746 - }, - { - "cycle": 4, - "before": 0.05143548548221588, - "after": 0.05557813495397568, - "change_pct": 8.05406896216065 - }, - { - "cycle": 6, - "before": 0.09103044867515564, - "after": 0.05937270447611809, - "change_pct": -34.77709344486368 - }, - { - "cycle": 7, - "before": 0.05341989919543266, - "after": 0.04115716740489006, - "change_pct": -22.955363029945687 - }, - { - "cycle": 8, - "before": 0.04590931162238121, - "after": 0.08533764630556107, - "change_pct": 85.88308839716555 - }, - { - "cycle": 9, - "before": 0.07381142675876617, - "after": 0.08571228384971619, - "change_pct": 16.12332617528845 - }, - { - "cycle": 10, - "before": 0.041892554610967636, - "after": 0.04548962414264679, - "change_pct": 8.586417240684163 - }, - { - "cycle": 11, - "before": 0.0932849571108818, - "after": 0.08449830114841461, - "change_pct": -9.419156351246496 - }, - { - "cycle": 12, - "before": 0.08388970792293549, - "after": 0.04014965891838074, - "change_pct": -52.13994670804689 - }, - { - "cycle": 13, - "before": 0.06404407322406769, - "after": 0.05953206494450569, - "change_pct": -7.045161327850067 - }, - { - "cycle": 15, - "before": 0.04169857129454613, - "after": 0.03787902370095253, - "change_pct": -9.159900387506003 - }, - { - "cycle": 16, - "before": 0.06094907596707344, - "after": 0.08402653783559799, - "change_pct": 37.86351392922134 - }, - { - "cycle": 17, - "before": 0.0639064759016037, - "after": 0.056689705699682236, - "change_pct": -11.292705629759757 - } - ], - "phi_volatility": [ - { - "cycle": 2, - "before": 0.10855834991032601, - "after": 0.16841283695960296, - "change_pct": 55.1357745385034 - }, - { - "cycle": 3, - "before": 0.17558011347041047, - "after": 0.04896096402167917, - "change_pct": -72.11474405959405 - }, - { - "cycle": 4, - "before": 0.07466645995874811, - "after": 0.05279484521936464, - "change_pct": -29.29242226224084 - }, - { - "cycle": 6, - "before": 0.06189083576042044, - "after": 0.0654327530550365, - "change_pct": 5.722846122690649 - }, - { - "cycle": 7, - "before": 0.06809056426481482, - "after": 0.052850661194263154, - "change_pct": -22.38181344963056 - }, - { - "cycle": 8, - "before": 0.06161526987324141, - "after": 0.05580045271951762, - "change_pct": -9.437298847649906 - }, - { - "cycle": 10, - "before": 0.06614619963259206, - "after": 0.07194586788279099, - "change_pct": 8.76795383924259 - }, - { - "cycle": 11, - "before": 0.06001132643114628, - "after": 0.06786496122937351, - "change_pct": 13.086920861911056 - }, - { - "cycle": 12, - "before": 0.0706755685446072, - "after": 0.04369201309039633, - "change_pct": -38.179467119787056 - }, - { - "cycle": 14, - "before": 0.06635781642137384, - "after": 0.059912770893819495, - "change_pct": -9.712564208906663 - }, - { - "cycle": 16, - "before": 0.07671236068176557, - "after": 0.056152498214315845, - "change_pct": -26.801238137802187 - }, - { - "cycle": 17, - "before": 0.06428078143575053, - "after": 0.06830892720659502, - "change_pct": 6.266485380036457 - }, - { - "cycle": 18, - "before": 0.06109950368213237, - "after": 0.05552471778624602, - "change_pct": -9.124109951676436 - } - ], - "shannon_entropy": [ - { - "cycle": 6, - "before": 2.6649817845902337, - "after": 2.96259441584258, - "change_pct": 11.167529660924385 - }, - { - "cycle": 7, - "before": 2.9881278018422006, - "after": 3.180532173367633, - "change_pct": 6.438960589530805 - }, - { - "cycle": 8, - "before": 3.110603709645871, - "after": 2.34532825363726, - "change_pct": -24.602152104285075 - }, - { - "cycle": 9, - "before": 2.814169625558674, - "after": 2.483355184759259, - "change_pct": -11.755312749981837 - }, - { - "cycle": 11, - "before": 2.503444470435829, - "after": 2.635426450163963, - "change_pct": 5.272015468557882 - }, - { - "cycle": 12, - "before": 2.3254778467811366, - "after": 3.1252314994749355, - "change_pct": 34.39093835276893 - }, - { - "cycle": 13, - "before": 2.901839746056141, - "after": 3.104568189030246, - "change_pct": 6.986203950429412 - }, - { - "cycle": 16, - "before": 2.856004684101568, - "after": 2.4556155051536033, - "change_pct": -14.019205961978932 - } - ] - }, - "elapsed_seconds": 60.69525909423828 -} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/shared/discovery/closure_quality_report.json b/shared/discovery/closure_quality_report.json deleted file mode 100644 index a0ca4b2d..00000000 --- a/shared/discovery/closure_quality_report.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,64 +0,0 @@ -{ - "generated": "2026-04-05", - "total_exact": 98274, - "real_from_data": 13019, - "synthetic_enumerated": 83686, - "other": 1569, - "multi_source_count": 6, - "top_convergences": [ - { - "value": 6.0, - "sources": [ - "auto-sync", - "auto-expand", - "auto-promote" - ], - "count": 7 - }, - { - "value": 28.0, - "sources": [ - "auto-sync", - "auto-expand", - "auto-promote" - ], - "count": 6 - }, - { - "value": 0.0, - "sources": [ - "auto-sync", - "auto-deep", - "auto-depth3" - ], - "count": 6 - }, - { - "value": 0.12, - "sources": [ - "auto-sync", - "auto-deep", - "auto-depth3" - ], - "count": 6 - }, - { - "value": 0.08, - "sources": [ - "auto-sync", - "auto-deep", - "auto-depth3" - ], - "count": 5 - }, - { - "value": 0.71, - "sources": [ - "auto-deep", - "auto-promote", - "auto-depth3" - ], - "count": 3 - } - ] -} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/shared/discovery/forge_result.json b/shared/discovery/forge_result.json deleted file mode 100644 index ad87150d..00000000 --- a/shared/discovery/forge_result.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1 +0,0 @@ -{"generated":0,"accepted":0,"lenses":[]} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/shared/discovery/reality_map_zscore_v9.3.json b/shared/discovery/reality_map_zscore_v9.3.json deleted file mode 100644 index 4aa3ec9c..00000000 --- a/shared/discovery/reality_map_zscore_v9.3.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,110 +0,0 @@ -{ - "reality_map_version": "v9.4", - "reality_map_total_nodes": 3847, - "generated": "2026-04-09T16:02:43", - "script": "monte_carlo_n6_v9_3.py", - "seed": 20260409, - "n_trials": 10000, - "random_set_size": 7, - "random_range": [ - 1, - 30 - ], - "previous_v5.0": { - "natural_big_z": 3.06, - "engineering_z": 1.75 - }, - "target_z_gt": 5.0, - "results": { - "full": { - "label": "FULL (1..10^4)", - "n_targets": 1988, - "max_result": 10000, - "match_mode": "exact", - "match_tol": 0.0, - "n6_constants": [ - 6, - 12, - 4, - 2, - 5, - 24, - 1 - ], - "n6_reachable_size": 51, - "n6_hits": 1388, - "n6_hit_rate": 0.6981891348088531, - "n_trials": 10000, - "random_mean": 1205.2103, - "random_std": 179.96817516969492, - "random_min": 283, - "random_max": 1519, - "z_score": 1.0156779098729243, - "p_value": 0.1329, - "count_ge": 1329, - "efficiency": { - "n6_efficiency": 27.215686274509803, - "random_mean": 20.534182363209002, - "random_std": 3.487554776524547, - "z_score": 1.915813324646651, - "p_value": 0.0459 - }, - "size_matched": { - "n_matched": 2469, - "size_tolerance": 5, - "random_mean": 1145.886593762657, - "random_std": 166.24181278622476, - "z_score": 1.456392962633798, - "p_value": 0.02754151478331308 - } - }, - "natural_big": { - "label": "NATURAL_BIG (100..10^9, log±0.01)", - "n_targets": 521, - "max_result": 1000000000, - "match_mode": "log_tol", - "match_tol": 0.01, - "n6_constants": [ - 6, - 12, - 4, - 2, - 5, - 24, - 1 - ], - "n6_reachable_size": 65, - "n6_hits": 46, - "n6_hit_rate": 0.08829174664107485, - "n_trials": 10000, - "random_mean": 60.6222, - "random_std": 24.111409480990527, - "random_min": 5, - "random_max": 155, - "z_score": -0.606443186638598, - "p_value": 0.6972, - "count_ge": 6972, - "efficiency": { - "n6_efficiency": 0.7076923076923077, - "random_mean": 0.8281868856587822, - "random_std": 0.2965712799972153, - "z_score": -0.406292133100703, - "p_value": 0.597 - }, - "size_matched": { - "n_matched": 2671, - "size_tolerance": 6, - "random_mean": 55.384500187195805, - "random_std": 20.79219281442205, - "z_score": -0.45134730477713014, - "p_value": 0.6248596031448895 - } - } - }, - "passed_target": { - "full_hit_z_gt_5": false, - "full_best_z": 1.915813324646651, - "natural_big_hit_z_gt_5": false, - "natural_big_best_z": -0.406292133100703 - } -} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/shared/discovery/reality_map_zscore_v9.3_revised.json b/shared/discovery/reality_map_zscore_v9.3_revised.json deleted file mode 100644 index 0e4aa8b1..00000000 --- a/shared/discovery/reality_map_zscore_v9.3_revised.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,57 +0,0 @@ -{ - "reality_map_version": "v9.4", - "total_nodes": 3847, - "generated": "2026-04-09T16:28:36", - "n6_constants": [ - 6, - 12, - 4, - 2, - 5, - 24, - 1 - ], - "seed": 20260409, - "n_trials": 10000, - "variants": { - "small_tight": { - "label": "SMALL_TIGHT 1..12", - "n_targets": 1129, - "n6_hits": 1129, - "n6_reach": 12, - "z_hit": 0.39946774732653584, - "z_eff": -0.21499348456056377, - "z_sm": 0.40977060706932744, - "best_z": 0.40977060706932744, - "p_hit": 0.7368, - "mean": 1093.929, - "std": 87.79432190637388 - }, - "core_tag": { - "label": "CORE_TAG thread+EXACT", - "n_targets": 680, - "n6_hits": 652, - "n6_reach": 51, - "z_hit": 1.1523511264399369, - "z_eff": 1.8798877597142039, - "z_sm": 1.4029745981479567, - "best_z": 1.8798877597142039, - "p_hit": 0.0044, - "mean": 540.2665, - "std": 96.96133186868877 - }, - "full": { - "label": "FULL 1..10^4", - "n_targets": 1988, - "n6_hits": 1388, - "n6_reach": 51, - "z_hit": 1.0156779098729243, - "z_eff": 1.915813324646651, - "z_sm": 1.456392962633798, - "best_z": 1.915813324646651, - "p_hit": 0.1329, - "mean": 1205.2103, - "std": 179.96817516969492 - } - } -} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/shared/harness/bitter-gate.hexa b/shared/harness/bitter-gate.hexa index f7d94cbf..fd65e025 100644 --- a/shared/harness/bitter-gate.hexa +++ b/shared/harness/bitter-gate.hexa @@ -91,17 +91,26 @@ if len(ids) == 0 { } // min_samples 가드 — 로그 누적 부족 시 "insufficient_data" 로 표기 -// 기본 50: lint_log + gc_log 전체 라인 수가 이보다 적으면 dormant 판정 미루고 보류 let MIN_SAMPLES: i64 = 50 let lint_lines = to_int(_str(exec("wc -l < '" + LINT_LOG + "' 2>/dev/null || echo 0")).trim()) let gc_lines = to_int(_str(exec("wc -l < '" + GC_LOG + "' 2>/dev/null || echo 0")).trim()) let total_samples = lint_lines + gc_lines let insufficient = total_samples < MIN_SAMPLES +// 규칙이 lint.hexa 에 실제 구현되었는지 확인 — 그레이 있으면 구현, 없으면 미구현 +// 미구현 규칙은 dormant 로 잘못 판정하지 않도록 "not_implemented" 로 표기 +let LINT_FILE = REPO_ROOT + "/shared/harness/lint.hexa" +fn is_implemented(rule: string) -> bool { + let cmd = "grep -c '\"" + rule + "|\\|" + rule + "-L' '" + LINT_FILE + "' 2>/dev/null || echo 0" + let c = to_int(_str(exec(cmd)).trim()) + return c > 0 +} + let ts = now_iso() let mut dormant: i64 = 0 let mut active: i64 = 0 let mut insufficient_cnt: i64 = 0 +let mut not_implemented: i64 = 0 for r in ids { let rule = _str(r) @@ -109,22 +118,26 @@ for r in ids { let lint_hits = hit_count(LINT_LOG, rule, window) let gc_hits = hit_count(GC_LOG, rule, window) let total = lint_hits + gc_hits + let implemented = is_implemented(rule) let mut status = "active" if total == 0 { - if insufficient { status = "insufficient_data" } + if !implemented { status = "not_implemented" } + else if insufficient { status = "insufficient_data" } else { status = "dormant" } } if status == "dormant" { dormant = dormant + 1 } else if status == "active" { active = active + 1 } + else if status == "not_implemented" { not_implemented = not_implemented + 1 } else { insufficient_cnt = insufficient_cnt + 1 } - let line = "{\"ts\":\"" + ts + "\",\"rule\":\"" + rule + "\",\"lint_hits\":" + to_string(lint_hits) + ",\"gc_hits\":" + to_string(gc_hits) + ",\"total\":" + to_string(total) + ",\"status\":\"" + status + "\",\"window\":" + to_string(window) + ",\"samples\":" + to_string(total_samples) + "}" + let line = "{\"ts\":\"" + ts + "\",\"rule\":\"" + rule + "\",\"lint_hits\":" + to_string(lint_hits) + ",\"gc_hits\":" + to_string(gc_hits) + ",\"total\":" + to_string(total) + ",\"status\":\"" + status + "\",\"window\":" + to_string(window) + ",\"samples\":" + to_string(total_samples) + ",\"implemented\":" + (if implemented { "true" } else { "false" }) + "}" try { exec("echo '" + line.replace("'", "'\\''") + "' >> '" + USAGE_LOG + "'") } catch e {} } println("audited: " + to_string(len(ids)) + " rules") println("active: " + to_string(active)) -println("dormant: " + to_string(dormant) + " (폐기 후보)") +println("dormant: " + to_string(dormant) + " (실제 폐기 후보 — lint 구현됨 + 히트 0)") +println("not_impl: " + to_string(not_implemented) + " (lint 미구현 — 수동 오버헤드)") println("insufficient: " + to_string(insufficient_cnt) + " (샘플 부족 — min_samples=" + to_string(MIN_SAMPLES) + ", 현재=" + to_string(total_samples) + ")") println("log: shared/harness/rules_usage.jsonl") exit(0) diff --git a/shared/harness/lint.hexa b/shared/harness/lint.hexa index 15240399..e61b2484 100644 --- a/shared/harness/lint.hexa +++ b/shared/harness/lint.hexa @@ -458,6 +458,34 @@ fn check_hx4(path: string) -> string { return "" } +// ─── VD1 (void 전용) — Terminal.app 단일 참조 ─── +// 금지: iTerm2 / kitty / Warp / Ghostty / Alacritty 언급 +// 스캔 범위: source 레이어만 (.hexa / .c / .m). 문서·규칙 파일은 rule 기술을 위해 예외. +// 예외: // @allow-terminal-mention 주석 +fn _vd1_is_exempt(path: string) -> bool { + if path.starts_with("archive/") { return true } + if path.starts_with("docs/") { return true } + if path.index_of("/_archive/") >= 0 { return true } + if path == "rules.json" { return true } + if path == "CLAUDE.md" { return true } + if path.starts_with("shared/harness/") { return true } + return false +} + +fn check_vd1(path: string) -> string { + if _project_name() != "void" { return "" } + if _vd1_is_exempt(path) { return "" } + let e = ext_of(path) + if e != ".hexa" && e != ".c" && e != ".m" { return "" } + let full = REPO_ROOT + "/" + path + let cmd = "grep -iE '\\biTerm2?\\b|\\bkitty\\b|\\bWarp\\b|\\bGhostty\\b|\\bAlacritty\\b' '" + full + "' 2>/dev/null | grep -v '@allow-terminal-mention' | wc -l" + let hits = to_int(_str(exec(cmd)).trim()) + if hits > 0 { + return "VD1|error|VD1 — Terminal.app 단일 참조 위반 (외부 에뮬레이터 " + to_string(hits) + "건; 예외 // @allow-terminal-mention)" + } + return "" +} + // ─── Check R19: SILENT EXIT 금지 — exit(1) 전 stderr 출력 필수 + catch 로그 필수 ─── // 탐지 2종: // (1) exit(1) 직전 5줄에 println/eprintln/>&2/stderr 없음 @@ -677,6 +705,10 @@ for f in files { let v11 = check_hx4(path) if v11 != "" { violations = violations.push(path + "|" + v11) } + // check_vd1 (void 프로젝트 전용): 외부 터미널 에뮬레이터 언급 금지 + let v12 = check_vd1(path) + if v12 != "" { violations = violations.push(path + "|" + v12) } + // check_pkill_substring (R20): pkill/pgrep -f substring 금지 if e == ".hexa" || e == ".sh" { let v12 = check_pkill_substring(path) diff --git a/shared/hooks/block_local_data.hexa b/shared/hooks/block_local_data.hexa deleted file mode 100755 index b0d979eb..00000000 --- a/shared/hooks/block_local_data.hexa +++ /dev/null @@ -1,47 +0,0 @@ -// block_local_data.hexa — 데이터 파일 중앙화 강제 (block_local_data.py 대체) -// PreToolUse: Write/Edit 시 데이터 파일을 nexus/shared 외부에 생성하려면 차단 - -let stdin_data = read_stdin() - -fn json_field(json_text: str, field: str) -> str { - let key = "\"" + field + "\"" - if json_text.contains(key) == false { return "" } - let parts = json_text.split(key) - if parts.len() < 2 { return "" } - let after = parts[1].trim() - if after.starts_with(":") == false { return "" } - let val_part = after.split(":")[1].trim() - if val_part.starts_with("\"") { - let inner = val_part.split("\"") - if inner.len() >= 2 { return inner[1] } - } - return "" -} - -let tool = json_field(stdin_data, "tool_name") -let file_path = json_field(stdin_data, "file_path") - -if len(file_path) == 0 { exit(0) } -if tool != "Write" && tool != "Edit" { exit(0) } - -// 허용 패턴 -if file_path.contains("/nexus/shared/") { exit(0) } -if file_path.contains("/nexus/mk2_hexa/") { exit(0) } -if file_path.contains("hexa_grammar.jsonl") { exit(0) } -if file_path.contains("package.json") { exit(0) } -if file_path.contains("tsconfig.json") { exit(0) } - -// 차단 패턴 -let blocked_names = [ - ".jsonl", "discovered_constants", "discovery_log", "growth_bus", - "verified_constants", "n6_constants", "n6_knowledge", - "alien_index_records", "growth_strategies", "scan_priority", - "bt_domains", "bt_keywords", "custom_lenses", "unfold_base" -] - -for pattern in blocked_names { - if file_path.contains(pattern) { - print_err("BLOCKED: " + file_path + " -- 데이터 파일은 nexus/shared/에만 저장. 규칙: 프로젝트 데이터 -> nexus/shared/ (유일한 진실의 원천)") - exit(1) - } -}