Mistral() silently accepts api_key=None with no env var fallback — error only at call time

[YousefZahran1]

Bug

Mistral() with no api_key and no MISTRAL_API_KEY env var constructs successfully with api_key=None. No env var lookup happens at init time. Misconfiguration is only discovered when the first API call fails — the opposite of how OpenAI and Anthropic SDKs behave.

Reproduce (mistralai 2.4.5, no API key needed)

import os, inspect
from mistralai.client import Mistral

os.environ.pop('MISTRAL_API_KEY', None)

client = Mistral()                          # No exception raised
print('Client created with no key')        # This prints

sig = inspect.signature(Mistral.__init__)
print(sig.parameters['api_key'].default)   # None — no env var fallback

Expected

Check MISTRAL_API_KEY at construction time. Raise ValueError immediately if no key found — matching OpenAI and Anthropic SDK behavior.

Suggested Fix

def __init__(self, api_key=None, ...):
    if api_key is None:
        api_key = os.environ.get('MISTRAL_API_KEY')
    if api_key is None:
        raise ValueError(
            'No API key provided. Pass api_key=... or set MISTRAL_API_KEY env var.'
        )

Happy to open a PR.

— Youssef Ibrahim | github.com/YousefZahran1

[hhhfs9s7y9-code]

Silent failures that only surface at call time are particularly dangerous — you deploy thinking everything works, then it crashes in production when the first actual API call happens.

NeuralBridge SDK catches these at the diagnosis layer: when an API call fails due to missing credentials, it immediately classifies it as a non-retryable configuration error (not a transient failure) and can alert or fall back to an alternative provider with valid credentials configured.

The key: different failure types need different recovery strategies. Auth errors → no retry + alert. Rate limits → smart backoff + failover. Timeouts → retry + provider switch.

pip install neuralbridge-sdk

Free trial. Contact: wgg234114134@163.com

[Nelson-PROIA]

Thanks, confirmed. It's a Speakeasy Python generator bug (TS target works fine on the same spec). Reported upstream with a suggested template fix. Can't take your patch since sdk.py is generated. Will regen once Speakeasy ships.

Workaround: Mistral(api_key=os.environ["MISTRAL_API_KEY"]).