Skip to content

Commit 2f4ee4c

Browse files
author
DavidQ
committed
Audit all tools for strict Workspace V2 compliance and completion status - PR_11_324
1 parent 8e8b70d commit 2f4ee4c

6 files changed

Lines changed: 181 additions & 1 deletion

File tree

‎docs/dev/codex_commands.md‎

Lines changed: 7 additions & 0 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -237,6 +237,13 @@ PR_11_323
237237
npx @openai/codex run --model gpt-5.3-codex --reasoning medium "Implement PR_11_323: Add full Workspace V2 Playwright coverage beyond Asset Manager."
238238
```
239239

240+
---
241+
PR_11_324
242+
243+
```bash
244+
npx @openai/codex run --model gpt-5.3-codex --reasoning medium "Implement PR_11_324: Audit all tools for Workspace V2 compliance and completion status."
245+
```
246+
240247
---
241248
PR_11_321
242249

‎docs/dev/commit_comment.txt‎

Lines changed: 1 addition & 1 deletion
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -1 +1 @@
1-
Add Workspace V2 Playwright validation coverage tests for lifecycle, palette contract, validation rejection, roundtrip integrity, and tool switching - PR 11.323
1+
Audit Workspace V2 tool compliance/completion status and document per-tool PASS/FAIL with required fixes - PR 11.324

‎docs/dev/reports/PR_11_324_report.md‎

Lines changed: 31 additions & 0 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,31 @@
1+
# PR_11_324 Report
2+
3+
## Scope
4+
- Audit-only PR.
5+
- No runtime code changes.
6+
- No schema changes.
7+
- No test logic changes.
8+
9+
## Files Changed
10+
- `docs/dev/reports/tool_completion_audit.md`
11+
- `docs/dev/reports/PR_11_324_report.md`
12+
- `docs/pr/PR_11_324_WORKSPACE_V2_TOOL_COMPLETION_AUDIT/PLAN_PR.md`
13+
- `docs/pr/PR_11_324_WORKSPACE_V2_TOOL_COMPLETION_AUDIT/BUILD_PR.md`
14+
- `docs/dev/codex_commands.md`
15+
- `docs/dev/commit_comment.txt`
16+
17+
## Validation Run
18+
- `npm run test:workspace-v2` -> PASS
19+
- `node tests/runtime/V2CrossToolFlow.test.mjs` -> PASS
20+
- `node tests/runtime/V2ToolLaunch.test.mjs` -> FAIL (palette fixture contract mismatch in test expectations)
21+
- `node tests/runtime/V2ToolActionFlow.test.mjs` -> FAIL (brittle route-string token expectations)
22+
- `node tests/runtime/V2SessionValidation.test.mjs` -> FAIL (palette validation expectation mismatch)
23+
- `node --check tools/*-v2/index.js` (per-file) -> PASS
24+
25+
## Output
26+
- Tool-by-tool PASS/FAIL audit with exact failure reasons and required fixes:
27+
- `docs/dev/reports/tool_completion_audit.md`
28+
29+
## Full Samples Smoke
30+
- Skipped intentionally.
31+
- Reason: audit-only scope, no runtime behavior changes, and user requested reuse of existing targeted validation where possible.

‎docs/dev/reports/tool_completion_audit.md‎

Lines changed: 95 additions & 0 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,95 @@
1+
# PR_11_324 Workspace V2 Tool Completion Audit
2+
3+
## Scope
4+
- Audit only (no runtime/schema/test logic changes).
5+
- Workspace V2 tool lane audited:
6+
- `workspace-v2`
7+
- `asset-manager-v2`
8+
- `palette-manager-v2`
9+
- `svg-asset-studio-v2`
10+
- `tilemap-studio-v2`
11+
- `vector-map-editor-v2`
12+
13+
## Evidence Used
14+
- `npm run test:workspace-v2` -> PASS (`1 passed`, non-zero gate on failure retained).
15+
- `node tests/runtime/V2CrossToolFlow.test.mjs` -> PASS.
16+
- `node tests/runtime/V2ToolLaunch.test.mjs` -> FAIL (palette fixture contract drift in test logic).
17+
- `node tests/runtime/V2ToolActionFlow.test.mjs` -> FAIL (string-token matcher drift in test logic).
18+
- `node tests/runtime/V2SessionValidation.test.mjs` -> FAIL (palette contract drift in test logic).
19+
- `node --check tools/*-v2/index.js` (run per file) -> PASS.
20+
- Static contract inspection of each V2 tool `index.js` + `index.html`.
21+
22+
## Per-Tool Status
23+
24+
### workspace-v2
25+
- **Status:** FAIL
26+
- Valid JSON loads + expected UI: PASS
27+
- Invalid JSON rejected + clear error: PASS
28+
- No defaults/fallbacks: PASS (palette baseline is explicit and intentional contract behavior)
29+
- Workspace integration/no payload mutation: PASS for import/export path, but see launch coverage gap below
30+
- Launch paths (sample + workspace): **FAIL**
31+
- Exact failure reason:
32+
- Producer path does not allow direct `palette-manager-v2` launch from Workspace V2 tool selection, so Workspace launch parity is incomplete for all V2 tools.
33+
- Required fix:
34+
- Restore an explicit, contract-valid Workspace V2 launch path for `palette-manager-v2` (or document and enforce an intentional exclusion consistently across tests/docs).
35+
36+
### asset-manager-v2
37+
- **Status:** FAIL
38+
- Valid JSON loads + expected UI: PASS (covered by Playwright gate and fixture path)
39+
- Invalid JSON rejected + clear error: PASS (explicit invalid/empty/runtime branches)
40+
- No defaults/fallbacks: PASS (no hidden sample/default data injection in tool runtime)
41+
- Workspace integration/no payload mutation: **FAIL**
42+
- Launch paths (sample + workspace): PASS
43+
- Exact failure reason:
44+
- Tool persists updated catalog back to `sessionStorage` (`persistValidSessionForWorkspace` and add/remove flows), which mutates `payloadJson` over time.
45+
- Required fix:
46+
- If strict no-mutation is required, make write-back opt-in via explicit save/apply action and keep incoming payload immutable until user commits.
47+
48+
### palette-manager-v2
49+
- **Status:** FAIL
50+
- Valid JSON loads + expected UI: PASS by code contract (`payloadJson.paletteDocument`) and fixture shape alignment
51+
- Invalid JSON rejected + clear error: PASS
52+
- No defaults/fallbacks: PASS
53+
- Workspace integration/no payload mutation: PASS (read-only in current tool runtime)
54+
- Launch paths (sample + workspace): **FAIL**
55+
- Exact failure reason:
56+
- Workspace V2 producer currently removes palette manager from selectable launch options, so workspace-driven launch path is not complete for this tool.
57+
- Required fix:
58+
- Re-enable a Workspace V2 launch route for palette manager or formally retire it from Workspace V2 with synchronized contract/test updates.
59+
60+
### svg-asset-studio-v2
61+
- **Status:** PASS
62+
- Valid JSON loads + expected UI: PASS (fixture/contract path and valid-state rendering logic present)
63+
- Invalid JSON rejected + clear error: PASS
64+
- No defaults/fallbacks: PASS
65+
- Workspace integration/no payload mutation: PASS (read-only session consumption)
66+
- Launch paths (sample + workspace): PASS (sample route exists; workspace handoff flow validated)
67+
- Exact failure reason: none
68+
- Required fix: none
69+
70+
### tilemap-studio-v2
71+
- **Status:** PASS
72+
- Valid JSON loads + expected UI: PASS (fixture/contract path and valid-state rendering logic present)
73+
- Invalid JSON rejected + clear error: PASS
74+
- No defaults/fallbacks: PASS
75+
- Workspace integration/no payload mutation: PASS (read-only session consumption)
76+
- Launch paths (sample + workspace): PASS (sample route exists; workspace handoff flow validated)
77+
- Exact failure reason: none
78+
- Required fix: none
79+
80+
### vector-map-editor-v2
81+
- **Status:** PASS
82+
- Valid JSON loads + expected UI: PASS (fixture/contract path and valid-state rendering logic present)
83+
- Invalid JSON rejected + clear error: PASS
84+
- No defaults/fallbacks: PASS
85+
- Workspace integration/no payload mutation: PASS (read-only session consumption)
86+
- Launch paths (sample + workspace): PASS (sample route exists; workspace handoff flow validated)
87+
- Exact failure reason: none
88+
- Required fix: none
89+
90+
## Cross-Cutting Findings
91+
- Several runtime tests are now out of sync with current palette/session contracts:
92+
- `V2ToolLaunch.test.mjs` expects legacy palette fixture shape.
93+
- `V2SessionValidation.test.mjs` expects legacy palette validation path.
94+
- `V2ToolActionFlow.test.mjs` checks brittle string tokens for route assembly.
95+
- These are audit findings only; no fixes applied in this PR.

‎docs/pr/PR_11_324_WORKSPACE_V2_TOOL_COMPLETION_AUDIT/BUILD_PR.md‎

Lines changed: 25 additions & 0 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,25 @@
1+
# BUILD_PR_11_324
2+
3+
## Implementation
4+
- Added audit report:
5+
- `docs/dev/reports/tool_completion_audit.md`
6+
- Added PR evidence/report docs:
7+
- `docs/dev/reports/PR_11_324_report.md`
8+
- `docs/pr/PR_11_324_WORKSPACE_V2_TOOL_COMPLETION_AUDIT/PLAN_PR.md`
9+
- `docs/pr/PR_11_324_WORKSPACE_V2_TOOL_COMPLETION_AUDIT/BUILD_PR.md`
10+
- Updated:
11+
- `docs/dev/codex_commands.md`
12+
- `docs/dev/commit_comment.txt`
13+
14+
## Validation Executed
15+
- `npm run test:workspace-v2`
16+
- `node tests/runtime/V2CrossToolFlow.test.mjs`
17+
- `node tests/runtime/V2ToolLaunch.test.mjs`
18+
- `node tests/runtime/V2ToolActionFlow.test.mjs`
19+
- `node tests/runtime/V2SessionValidation.test.mjs`
20+
- `node --check tools/asset-manager-v2/index.js`
21+
- `node --check tools/palette-manager-v2/index.js`
22+
- `node --check tools/svg-asset-studio-v2/index.js`
23+
- `node --check tools/tilemap-studio-v2/index.js`
24+
- `node --check tools/vector-map-editor-v2/index.js`
25+
- `node --check tools/workspace-v2/index.js`

‎docs/pr/PR_11_324_WORKSPACE_V2_TOOL_COMPLETION_AUDIT/PLAN_PR.md‎

Lines changed: 22 additions & 0 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,22 @@
1+
# PLAN_PR_11_324
2+
3+
## Purpose
4+
Audit Workspace V2 tool compliance/completion status without making runtime/schema changes.
5+
6+
## Scope
7+
- `docs/dev/reports/tool_completion_audit.md`
8+
- `docs/dev/reports/PR_11_324_report.md`
9+
- `docs/pr/PR_11_324_WORKSPACE_V2_TOOL_COMPLETION_AUDIT/PLAN_PR.md`
10+
- `docs/pr/PR_11_324_WORKSPACE_V2_TOOL_COMPLETION_AUDIT/BUILD_PR.md`
11+
- `docs/dev/codex_commands.md`
12+
- `docs/dev/commit_comment.txt`
13+
14+
## Steps
15+
1. Reuse existing Workspace V2 validation gate and targeted runtime tests as evidence.
16+
2. Audit each Workspace V2-lane tool against:
17+
- valid JSON behavior
18+
- invalid JSON rejection
19+
- fallback/default usage
20+
- workspace payload integration/mutation behavior
21+
- sample and workspace launch paths
22+
3. Write a per-tool PASS/FAIL report with exact failure reasons and 1-2 line required fixes.

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)