diff --git a/actions/AddReviewpageaction.py b/actions/AddReviewpageaction.py
index 6d60740..7b23752 100644
--- a/actions/AddReviewpageaction.py
+++ b/actions/AddReviewpageaction.py
@@ -21,3 +21,12 @@ def enterfeedback(self,feedback):
         self.send_keys(self.arp.reviewtext,feedback)
     def clicksubmit(self):
         self.click(self.arp.writeReview)
+    def successmsg(self,expectedMessage):
+        actualMessage = self.get_text(self.arp.successMessage)
+        print(actualMessage)
+        assert expectedMessage in actualMessage
+    def warningmsg(self,expectedMessage):
+        actualMessage = self.get_text(self.arp.warningMessage)
+        print(actualMessage)
+        assert expectedMessage in actualMessage
+
diff --git a/data_provider/DataProvider.xlsx b/data_provider/DataProvider.xlsx
index aacd16b..25f8a3a 100644
Binary files a/data_provider/DataProvider.xlsx and b/data_provider/DataProvider.xlsx differ
diff --git a/pages/Addreviewpage.py b/pages/Addreviewpage.py
index d4e023f..ef635fd 100644
--- a/pages/Addreviewpage.py
+++ b/pages/Addreviewpage.py
@@ -11,7 +11,7 @@ def __init__(self,driver):
     reviewname=	(By.CSS_SELECTOR,"input#input-name")
     reviewtext=	(By.XPATH,"//div[@class='form-group required']/child::textarea")
     writeReview=(By.XPATH , "//button[text()='Write Review']")
-    successMessage=(By.XPATH,"//h5[@class='content-title mb-3']/following-sibling::div[1]")
+    successMessage=(By.XPATH,"//div[contains(@class,'alert-success')]")
     warningMessage =(By.XPATH,"//div[contains(@class,'alert-danger')]")
 	
 
diff --git a/tests/test_addreview.py b/tests/test_addreview.py
index fd6ef54..2c515d3 100644
--- a/tests/test_addreview.py
+++ b/tests/test_addreview.py
@@ -3,9 +3,9 @@
 from actions.HomePageAction import HomePageAction
 from actions.AddReviewpageaction import AddReviewpageaction
 from utils.excelReader import get_data
-from utils.loggerCreator import get_logger
+from utils import loggerCreator
 
-logger = get_logger(__name__)
+logger = loggerCreator.get_logger(__name__)
 
 
 @pytest.mark.Jothika
@@ -25,9 +25,43 @@ def test_validAddreview(self,driver,rating,name,feedback,expectedMessage):
         url=ConfigReader.get_url()
         logger.info("Application launch is successful")
         self.arpa.selectproduct()
+        logger.info("Selected the product")
         self.arpa.moveto_review()
+        logger.info("Found review page")
         self.arpa.selectrating(rating)
+        logger.info("Selected Rating")
         self.arpa.enterName(name)
+        logger.info("Entered reviewer name")
         self.arpa.enterfeedback(feedback)
+        logger.info("Entered feedback")
         self.arpa.clicksubmit()
+        logger.info("Submitted review")
+        self.arpa.successmsg(expectedMessage)
+        logger.info("Review added successfully")
+
+    @pytest.mark.parametrize(
+        "rating,expectedMessage",
+        get_data(
+            "data_provider/DataProvider.xlsx",
+            "AddReview-rating",
+        ),
+    )
+
+    def test_withrating(self,driver,rating,expectedMessage):
+          drv, wait = driver
+          self.arpa=AddReviewpageaction(drv)
+          url=ConfigReader.get_url()
+          logger.info("Application launch is successful")
+          self.arpa.selectproduct()
+          logger.info("Selected the product")
+          self.arpa.moveto_review()
+          logger.info("Found review page")
+          self.arpa.selectrating(rating)
+          logger.info("Selected Rating")
+          self.arpa.clicksubmit()
+          logger.info("Submitted review")
+          self.arpa.warningmsg(expectedMessage)
+          logger.info("Invalid review submitted successfully")
+
+