Skip to content

Methods that specity the positional parameters of a contract method in the wrong order are considered valid #17

@KevinBrowne

Description

@KevinBrowne

If you specify a contract class, Sinject::Container#register will verify that the methods of the provided class accept parameters with the same names as in the contract. However, it does not check that positional parameters are in the correct order.

Steps to reproduce:

require 'sinject'
container = Sinject::Container.new(false)

class MyContract
  def family_then_given(given_name, family_name) = nil
end

class BadImpl
  def family_then_given(given_name, surname) = "#{surname}, #{given_name}"
end

container.register(key: :concatenator, class: BadImpl, contract: MyContract)
# => Sinject::DependencyContractInvalidParametersException
#    The method signature of method: 'family_then_given' does not match the contract parameters: 'family_name, surname'

class OutOfOrderImpl
  def family_then_given(family_name, given_name) = "#{family_name}, #{given_name}"
end

container.register(key: :concatenator, class: OutOfOrderImpl, contract: MyContract)

Expected:

Sinject::DependencyContractInvalidParametersException or similar error to be raised

Actual:

OutOfOrderImpl is considered to match the contract and is registered.

container.get(:concatenator).family_then_given('Kevin', 'Browne')
=> "Kevin, Browne"

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions