Skip to content

Add value type validation and improved error handling for custom components #380

@coderabbitai

Description

@coderabbitai

Description

The current implementation in ComponentBase.cs needs enhanced error handling and validation to ensure custom components meet ECS requirements.

Why Value Type Validation is Critical for ECS Components

In Entity-Component-System architectures, components must be value types (structs) for several important reasons:

1. Memory Layout and Performance

  • Components are stored in contiguous memory arrays (ComponentArray) for cache efficiency
  • Value types ensure predictable memory layouts without indirection
  • Reference types would introduce pointer chasing and memory fragmentation

2. Native Interop Requirements

  • The engine uses native interop with C++ code that expects fixed-size, POD (Plain Old Data) types
  • Reference types have unpredictable memory layouts and garbage collection concerns
  • Native code needs to safely read/write component data using raw pointers

3. Copy Semantics

  • ECS operations frequently copy components (e.g., when moving entities between archetypes)
  • Value types have well-defined copy semantics
  • Reference types would share state unexpectedly across component instances

4. Serialization and Networking

  • Components need to be serializable for save/load and networking
  • Value types can be directly serialized as binary blobs
  • Reference types require complex serialization handling

5. Thread Safety

  • Multiple systems may access the same component type concurrently
  • Value types eliminate shared mutable state concerns
  • Reference types would require synchronization mechanisms

Proposed Improvements

  1. Add value type validation - Reject reference types during component registration
  2. Improve exception handling - Catch specific reflection exceptions
  3. Add performance optimization - Cache discovered component types

Current Issues

  • Broad exception catching hides specific reflection errors
  • No validation ensures components are structs
  • Repeated reflection calls impact performance

References

Implementation Priority

High - This validation prevents runtime errors and ensures ECS performance characteristics.

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

Labels

No labels
No labels

Type

No type

Projects

Status

Todo

Relationships

None yet

Development

No branches or pull requests

Issue actions